We’ve been overpaying for charter school tuition for 25 years and its high time for the state legislature to fix it. How much are we spending on charter school tuition? For the 2021-2022 school year, our 500 districts paid over $2.6 billion in charter tuition — with $1.6 billion going to brick-and-mortar charters and just over $1 billion to cyber charters.
Pittsburgh, the state’s second largest school district, spent just over $94.3 million on brick-and-mortar charter tuition and an additional $19.6 million on cyber charter tuition.
Charter and cyber charter schools have a place in our public educational system and that they work well for many students. But flaws in the current formulas used to fund them result in school districts overpaying by hundreds of millions of dollars, which comes out of the pockets of local taxpayers and out of school district classrooms.
When districts overpay, they have fewer resources available for math and reading coaches, nurses, counselors, social workers or librarians, especially in our most underfunded districts that tend to serve students with the greatest needs.
93% of school boards in the state are calling for reform. Just two common-sense changes to the way we fund charter schools could save schools district millions of dollars, freeing up those resources to better serve students.
First, apply a flat, statewide tuition rate for all students enrolled in a cyber charter school. Cyber charter schools receive the same tuition payments from school districts as brick-and-mortar charter schools, even though they don’t have the same expenses as their brick-and-mortar colleagues, like building maintenance, utilities, food service, transportation, security, athletics, extracurriculars, and debt service. Cyber charters cost 25% to 30% less than brick-and-mortar schools.
Read More
And because each school district calculates its own unique tuition rates based upon the school district’s expenses, vastly different tuition rates are paid to the cyber charter school even though all students in the school are being provided the same education. In the current school year, regular education tuition rates for charter schools range from $7,921 to $25,150, special education tuition rates from $18,328 to $60,165.
Second, apply a tiered special education funding system for charter school students that more accurately reflects the actual costs of providing special education. The formula currently used to distribute state special education funding to school districts correctly recognizes that not all students identified for special education have the same educational needs and costs.
Unfortunately, charter school special education funding is still based on a flawed 25-year-old formula that bears no relation to what charter schools are actually spending to educate their students with disabilities. To start, the tuition rate paid by a school district for a special education student is based on the district’s expenses for providing special education to its own students.
In 2020-21, which is the latest year for which data are available from the Pennsylvania Department of Education (PDE), more than 93% of the students requiring the most extensive special education services were educated by or through a school district. This inflates school district tuition rates.
The same tuition rate is paid to the charter school regardless of the individual student’s needs. We know from PDE data that 93% of the special education students in charter schools require the least extensive special education services. The vast majority of time, the flawed formula results in overpayments.
What does this look like at the student level? If a special education student from the Pittsburgh Public School District who requires speech and language therapy services attends a charter school, the district would be required by law to send the charter school an additional $27,119 to cover the costs of providing the student with those services. However, if that same student were enrolled in a district school, those services might cost the district $5,000 to provide, giving the charter school an extra $22,119 more than they will spend to provide services to that student.
In the 2020-21 school year, charter schools received roughly $592 million dollars to provide their special education students with the supports and services that they needed for an education. Yet, charter schools only reported spending $406 million on special education. That’s almost $186 million in overpayments that could have been used by home school districts to not raise property taxes or to invest in programs to help their own students achieve.
School directors are urging the General Assembly to abandon the use of the outdated, unfair formula and enact legislation that fairly and more accurately pays charter schools based upon the needs and costs of each student and the education being provided.
Lawrence Feinberg, who is serving in his 24th year as a member of the Haverford School Board in Delaware County, is the director of the Keystone Center for Charter Change. His views are his own.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.