"Bulldozed," is the word almost everyone used to describe what Donald Trump did to Kaitlan Collins, the moderator of CNN's town hall with Mr. Trump. It turns out that CNN let the Trump campaign pick the audience, which was not only an extraordinary act of journalistic malpractice and gutlessness, but one of the reasons Mr. Trump was able to bulldoze — the audience was with him.
The moderator could control neither the candidate nor the hall. I am not sure any moderator could have.
This raises issues about how TV journalists should handle Mr. Trump in the future, one of which is fundamental and I will return to momentarily. But it also raises the matter of the hubris of the left: So much for the political demise of Donald Trump.
How many times has his end been announced and seemingly assured in the past? A friend told me months ago that he hopes the GOP nominates Mr. Trump because that would be a surefire Democratic win. Really? You might want to re-think that, guys.
The town hall reminded us of something that we forget at our peril: Mr. Trump is an extremely clever demagogue and nimble liar. He is not going away. And he will not be easy to beat.
The force of his will is titanic. Mr. Trump has written a new ending for King Lear.
Read More
By any rational measure, he has been ruined. His kingdom is gone. His wealth, credibility and reputation are, all, lost. He seems to have gone utterly mad. A normal person would be in ashes and rags, begging his Lord for mercy and solace.
But instead of a dark night of the soul and a breakthrough of character, this man puts on the long red tie, opens another golf course and goes on the attack: Even defaming anew the person who has just won a defamation lawsuit against him.
And the crowd (albeit handpicked) titters, stands and cheers.
Mr. Trump rolls on with his fantasies and half-baked logic, tickling the bruised egos of old white men throughout the land who feel that importance has eluded them.
It is interesting that Mr. Trump cannot manipulate the courts. But he can, expertly, manipulate televised and social media.
The late Sen. Eugene McCarthy once said that TV first ruined sports, and then politics. CNN and FOX have come pretty close. They have a lot to answer for when the history of the present time is written.
Without the ersatz journalism of our electronic media — gossip, panic and repetition being the formula — Trump is probably not possible. And the sheer bile and rulelessness of social media takes distraction and disinformation up yet another notch.
So, how do we protect truth, decency, democracy, and free speech?
We demand that people in the electronic media think. (Or at least hire people to think for them.)
CNN's argument is that Trump is who and what people are talking about. So, the network gave him a platform and carte blanche as to its use.
This is what the major media said in the early days of Joe McCarthy: We know he is lying and we know he is a mentally unstable demagogue. But we have to cover him.
Cover Trump, yes. But do not give him a rent-free megaphone. And when what he says is demonstrably false, tell the people. Print media has found a way to do this. Electronic media can, too.
Joe McCarthy is the only analogue I can think of for Mr. Trump. In the cases of both men, a popular power base was built on fear, resentment and lies. And the leader’s utter shamelessness.
Indeed, in a gesture reminiscent of Joe, Donald has taken to removing alleged evidentiary documents from his pocket: I have here … . It’s vile and cheap but effective, if no one calls the demagogue out.
Joe McCarthy self-destructed. He wasn't taken down by the brave and true. He drank himself to death. There were a few noble exceptions — people who tried to confront him: Attorney Joseph Welch; the other McCarthy (Gene actually debated Joe); and journos like Richard Rovere and I.F. Stone. A few like these stood up and spoke out. But, generally, the cowardice of the American political class toward Joe McCarthy was profound, almost palpable.
Demagogues feed on cowardice. Today, the cowardice is mostly in the GOP, with assists from FOX and, in at least one case, CNN.
But Donald Trump will not self-destruct. I think we know that after the town hall. And the cumulative court cases will not take him out either. He must be defeated at the polls — by politicians with courage and voters who finally say, "enough."
Democrats of courage must make an argument to the working class they lost. Traditional Republicans of courage must fight for their party.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com). His previous article was “The world has gotten better”.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.