That was it? The Illinois driving test was over: I passed easily. It was not like this in Singapore a few years ago when I failed even after nine months of weekly instruction. Nor was it like this some months ago when my mother failed multiple times in Tokyo — as a driver with over a decade of experience.

Maybe those tests are too hard. But maybe getting a driver’s license in America too easy. And these loose requirements may contribute to making motor vehicle accidents a leading cause of death in the US.

The road test in the US assesses fewer skills than in other countries. Here, beyond basic driving skills like observing the right-of-way and signaling and turning, we are only tested on the three-point turn and, in some states, parallel parking.

Pennsylvania requires parallel parking. The rules: “Park your vehicle midway between two uprights in a space that is 24 feet long and 8 feet wide. Your entire vehicle must be completely inside the space, and you cannot make contact with any of the uprights to the rear or front of your vehicle, cross over the painted line, or go up onto or over the curb.” You only get one try. That’s the hardest thing you have to do.

Advertise with us

But in Singapore, there are two parts to the road test, the “course” test and the road test. The first tests various skills, some as difficult as they sound: parallel parking, reverse parking, the three-point turn, moving a car parked on a slope, an “S” path. Yes, I failed. Seeing his car pull in early without leaving the course to drive on the road, my instructor knew.

And in Japan, there are few ways to pass but many ways to fail — instantly. All it takes is one wheel over the lane divider when turning.

Singapore and Japan are not the only countries with a difficult test. A woman in South Korea became an international sensation for passing her driving test after 960 attempts. And although not having made anyone an international star, the tests in European countries like Germany and Finland are still known for theoretical and practical rigor. In Finland, obtaining a driving license takes two years, not 4 weeks as it did for me, and it culminates in an exam testing driving in various conditions, including the winter with a slippery road course.

But do these countries have better drivers? They might. In 2019, Japan, Germany and Finland had around three times fewer motor-vehicle deaths per 10,000 registered vehicles than the US, according to the latest available CDC data. That data also place the US as the developed country with the highest motor-vehicle deaths per capita.

Although these disparities come from various factors — from drunk driving to distracted driving to speeding — inexperience in different road conditions is a big one. It is one part a consequence of age, and another part a consequence of a license whose requirements are “too easy,” as my driving instructor admitted.

Advertise with us

States that allow licenses for teens of around 16 to 17 generally have more teen driving fatalities than states that allow teens closer to 18. And the latest CDC data show that the group with the most motor vehicle crashes are teens aged 16 to 19.

Fortunately, Pennsylvania imposes stricter requirements, requiring drivers under 18 to have 65 hours of behind-the-wheel training before they can test for a license.

But even Pennsylvania’s standards are lower than the standards abroad. If easier tests, which need little experience to pass, allow poor drivers to get licenses, the solution seems simple. But it may be unpopular.

When I suggested the exam include at least u-turns and parallel parking in all states, my instructor told me that driving is associated with freedom. And that without consistent public transportation in many states, young Americans who cannot drive cannot travel: they feel almost under house arrest.

Still, more freedom means more accidents. Is it really worth the cost?

Advertise with us

This debate dates back at least sixty years, when policymakers and safety experts were unsure whether “stiffer driving tests” would reduce accidents, though they agreed that “the bad‐record driver is likely to be the fatal‐accident driver, too,” as a 1964 New York Times article reports. Auto accidents were the nation’s fourth ranking killer then, and were rising.

As a student, I know that when most of us prepare for the test, few of us prepare for reality. We often ignore what we need not learn. And when learning requires mistakes, we can make only so many when driving. Policymakers acknowledge this: They have researched many approaches to reducing crash rates, from graduated licensing programs to more supervised driving hours. But they need more data from further research and pilot programs on how testing a wider range of driving skills would improve road safety.

Then with tougher standards for student drivers, the instructors giving the road test — as one of them quipped at me — need not fear for their lives.

Aman Majmudar is a junior at the University of Chicago.