Educators’ lives became more complicated when we had to start accounting for ChatGPT. Suddenly, anyone could create a passing paper with the click of a button. The paper will lack critical thinking, individual problem posing, and personal investment, but it’ll sound good.
Imagine if we let AI write our public policies! The truth is, we already let someone else write our local public policies. That someone doesn’t care about critical thinking, solves the wrong problems, and is personally invested in advancing its own causes and not the public good.
What that someone does is called “copy-and-paste policy making” and it is on the rise, especially in education.
Between 2010 and 2018, state lawmakers introduced more than 10,000 “model bills.” More than half were written by industry lobbyists. Two lobbyist policy mills, the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) and the American Principles Project, tout model legislation that can “fill a gap” and “influence” state policies.
Why are industry lobbyists writing our policies? One study found that diminishing resources for legislative offices leaves staff without time to research potential policies. Underfunded state offices rely on lobbyists to do this research for them. Lack of time, money, and staff, then, eliminates independence in local democratic decision making.
Model bills are ideal for part-time legislators, like school board members, as well. Someone does the work for them and then they can put their names on the front page and champion the cause. In education, we call this plagiarism.
Here’s an example. Have you been hearing a lot about book bans? That’s because model legislative policies that include book banning have been shared across the U.S. Recent book bans in Bucks County and Penncrest School District reflect copy and paste model legislation.
An educator’s job is to empower our students with critical thinking skills and to encourage problem solving. Yet they are increasingly being asked to implement policies and curricula that are designed by lobbyists that have no investment in the students’ lives, communities, or overall well-being.
These policies are not tailored to the specific needs of a community and rarely take into account the voices of local families and educators. They are written by corporations and lobbyists who see our public schools as a potential incubator for their products or ideas. In essence, our students’ day-to-day lives are controlled by corporate and political interest groups.
The consequences of copy-and-paste legislation are far reaching. The rise in book bans and censorship in schools, for example, is driven by groups who want to control what our kids read and how they learn. They are not based on any kind of educational or pedagogical reasoning, but on a desire to impose a narrow worldview on your children. For example, Don Lee is part of the Advisory Council for ALEC but is also a lobbyist for a for-profit education company that is being sued for problematic recruiting and falsifying testing data. In essence, this for-profit corporation has a seat at your local policy table.
With this approach, we don’t safeguard our children. We shelter and disenfranchise them.
Local policy makers need to commit to researching and writing legislation that is representative of their local communities. That means that they need to listen to their local educators and families and tailor policies that make the community thrive.
We cannot continue to let corporations and lobbyists write our public policies, especially when it comes to education. We don’t let our students hire somebody else to do their homework for them. Let’s apply the same rules to our local politicians.
Brandi Lawless, chair of the Department of Communication Studies at the University of San Francisco, is a mother, community organizer and advocate. Her previous article was “I’m a former small-town Pennsylvanian turned liberal San Franciscan, and I want to change your politics.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.