Pennsylvania public schools are among the most unequal in the country, and this has real consequences for students. For too long, the resources available for education in public schools has been dependent on local wealth. State funding only covers 38% of the cost of education in Pennsylvania — a state share that ranks Pennsylvania 45th in the country. High dependency on local property taxes means many districts in poor rural or city areas don’t have the money to keep up.

A 2022 study from The Urban Institute found that Pennsylvania is one of the few states in which poor students actually receive less for their public education than their peers. In another national study, Research For Action (RFA) looked at educational opportunities in public schools across the country — access to resources like experienced teachers and college-prep coursework. RFA found that Pennsylvania has the largest gaps in educational opportunity in the nation between students of color and white students and the second largest gap between low-income students and their peers.

The 20% of districts with the least local wealth have $4,800 less funding per student than the wealthiest 20% of districts, according to state data analyzed in a study commissioned as part of the recent school funding trial. At the same time, these low-wealth districts serve a disproportionate share of students with greater needs: students in poverty, students learning English, and more. When student need is accounted for, that gap rises to $7,000 per student.

The lack of resources and inequality in Pennsylvania public schools are so stark that Commonwealth Court recently ruled that our funding system violates the Pennsylvania state constitution. As the court wrote in the conclusion of its opinion, “educators credibly testified to lacking the very resources state officials have identified as essential to student achievement.”

Advertise with us

I’ve seen the effects of our unconstitutional school funding system. Thanks to my involvement in AAUW and Education Voters PA, I have watched poorer districts struggle with these realities for years, and have listened to both parents and educators give voice to these issues. It is way past time for Pennsylvania to take advantage of its current budget surplus to right a significant wrong.

But in his April 5 opinion piece, Nathan Benefield of the Commonwealth Foundation attempts to paint a rosy picture of the school funding status quo.

Benefield’s claim that low-wealth public schools don’t suffer from a lack of funding will come as a surprise to families in those communities across the state. His focus on Pennsylvania’s average school spending — like our cost of living, it’s higher than the national average — papers over stark disparities in a state with 500 school districts, where concentrated poverty is often found across the street from concentrated wealth.

Benefield’s proposed solution for better education—school vouchers that allow state public school funds to be used for private school tuition — is far from commonsense. Florida’s new universal school voucher program, which Benefield praises, is a radical experiment that would provide taxpayer subsidies for wealthy families who are already enrolled in private schools.

The argument that vouchers improve educational quality is also dubious. An 2018 analysis from the Center for American Progress, examining program evaluations of voucher programs in Louisiana, Indiana, Ohio, and Washington D.C., found that students attending private schools through those programs performed significantly worse than their peers in public schools.

Advertise with us

Voucher programs also allow private schools to remain just that — private. Private schools can continue to legally turn away children who are behind grade level, who are learning English, who can’t afford full tuition, or who simply “don’t fit in.” It’s the school’s choice, not school choice.

What Pennsylvania students really need is for the state to support strong public schools—open to all, with locally elected school boards — in every community, regardless of wealth, that have the resources children need to meet their potential.

Cheryl Towers is an artist, retired non-profit management consultant, chair of the Fox Chapel Area Branch of AAUW, and a volunteer with Education Voters of Pennsylvania.