Whether you’re dutifully shopping at Giant Eagle or popping into your local Burgatory for its oxymoronic Standard Deluxe or just driving around chewing on a jalapeno Fatty smoked meat stick, like ya do, you are acutely aware that meat prices are up significantly from this time last year.
The exact dimensions of the increase can depend on factors ranging from your zip code to climate patterns to your particular carnivorous preferences, but generally 15% over 2024 seems to be the consensus on the beef spike. But don’t worry because a lot of purported meat experts are busy determining whom or what to blame.
The Trump administration blames cows.
And, of course, Biden. And, of course, immigrants.
And many others, but let’s start with cows.
It’s the immigrants’ fault
Last Sunday, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent went on Fox News to chat with Maria Bartiromo, who never met a load of nonsense she couldn’t abide and yet still didn’t land a job in the White House.
Maria had recently interviewed the CEO of Omaha Steaks, who said the price of beef, currently about $6.30, was on its way to $10 per pound and wasn’t likely to come down until 2027. She then asked the Treasury Secretary, a former hedge fund manager and a major Trump fundraiser, what he made of that prognosis.
The answer, fair warning, was a little twisty.
“Maria, the beef market is a very specialized market; it goes in long cycles. And this is the perfect storm, again, something we inherited and there’s also, because of the mass immigration, a disease that had been — we’ve been rid of in North America made its way up through South America, you know, as these migrants brought some of their cattle with them. So part of the problem is we’ve had to shut the border to Mexican beef because of this disease called screw worm. So we’re not going to let that get into our supply chain.”
There was more, but that was plenty.
Not surprisingly, the internet lost its mind generating a firehouse of snark at Bessent’s explanation, with plenty of commentary about migrants hoisting diseased cows over Trump’s border wall while others tried to recall images of South America migrants traveling with diseased cattle.
The fact is, Bessent was correct to the extent that Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins actually closed the border to Mexican cattle in July because of several cases of New World Screw Worm, though restrictions have eased somewhat since.
Further, Bessent didn’t claim there were diseased Mexican cows in the U.S., only that they’d arrived in North America, by which he meant Mexico. That’s technically correct, Mexico being north of Central America, but I guess it’s been a little harder to visualize since the administration changed the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America. (Note to New Mexico — stay loose).
It’s the ranchers’ fault
Otherwise, diseased cattle have more to do with beef prices than offshore windmills have to do with the mental health of whales (another Trump theory, honest to God), but not by all that much. Industry experts attribute the price hikes way more directly with droughts, feed costs, pricing cycles, supply chain issues, and — whatd’ya know? — tariffs.
Trump slapped a 50% tariff on Brazilian goods in July, at which point Brazilian beef exports immediately tanked. Tariffs on Brazil, Australia, New Zealand and Uruguay, on everything from beef to farm equipment to feed to machinery, all have a hand in higher prices and none of them made it into Bessent’s answer last Sunday.
The administration is strictly a blame exporter. Imports are zero and will remain so.
When Trump figured he could mitigate the beef issue with Argentinian imports, his buddies among America’s cattle ranchers just about had a cow.
“We love you and support you,” wrote the Wyoming-based Meriweather Farms cattle operation on social media, “but your suggestion to buy beef from Argentina to stabilize beef prices would be an absolute betrayal to the American cattle rancher.”
Trump took that well (snort!).
“If it weren’t for me, they would be doing just as they’ve done for the past 20 years — Terrible,” posted the president, who said ranchers “don’t understand that the only reason they are doing so well, for the first time in decades, is because I put Tariffs on cattle coming into the United States.”
It’s the packers’ fault
It’s a misunderstanding is it? Well don’t feel bad, you cattlemen; the administration has a similar shipment of blame for meat packers. Two weeks ago, Trump posted the allegation that the major packing operations were “driving up the price of Beef, through Illicit Collusion, Price Fixing, and Price Manipulation.”
It took Attorney General Pam Bondi about two minutes to post that a Department of Justice investigation was “underway.”
So fear not America, the administration won’t rest until it finds its meat prices scapegoat, even if it’s a scapecow.
Gene Collier is a columnist for the Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and on Bluesky: @genecollier.bsky.social.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.