Regardless of its legal outcome and the fact that it could easily be rendered moot within days, Tuesday’s collision at the Supreme Court will find a dark place in history as a rock bottom moment in American governance.
For the second time in five days, the Trump administration was in front of the Court arguing that 42 million Americans, most of them children and the elderly, including disabled people and more than a million veterans, should not be getting, um, fed.
The branches crash
Big picture now: Three co-equal branches of government, as blueprinted in the Constitution of the United States, in a chain reaction crash at the intersection of idiocy and malevolence. The executive branch pleading with the judicial branch to sabotage the legislative branch, or in this case the money it appropriates annually for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP).
Even for an audience acutely familiar with reckless government incompetence, this was a breakout performance, pure breakdown lane stuff. Please move all vehicles to the shoulder.
No administration in history, not even the contemptuous and contemptible first Trump rodeo, was low enough to cut off SNAP benefits during a government shutdown. Not in the 60 odd years the program’s been up and running. No one had been that callous. No one, not even Trump in his early ’70s, had approached that level of moral bankruptcy.
Until 10 days ago, when in the fifth week of a government shutdown and the seventh week of vacation for the fully paid House of Representatives, the administration of the richest country on earth interrupted its boasts about taking in “trillions and trillions” of dollars and just stopped funding SNAP.
Slapped immediately with multiple court orders that amounted to “you can’t do that,” the administration referred everyone to its default position on this and everything else: “Screw you.”
As I was writing this, the Supreme Court was ostensibly determining the fate of the “argument,” but the damage to our collective soul was in the process, unmistakable and astonishing.
“Astonishing,” wrote Catherine Rampell in the Bulwark, “how hard this administration is working to keep people hungry. It’s clear they are trying to maximize public suffering, in hopes of getting people to blame Democrats for that suffering. But it’s transparently the White House working overtime to keep the suffering going!”
If you’ve stopped paying attention out of instinctive soul survival, that was smart, because every update in these SNAP legalympics has been more depressing.
The legalympics
This time last week, when some national grocery chains said they’d offer discounts to SNAP recipients who’d lost their benefits, the government agency that administers the program, the Department of Agriculture, sent out an email telling the grocers they couldn’t do that.
The administration first went to the Supreme Court after a lower court ruled that it must fund SNAP fully for November. Justice Ketanji Brown-Jackson issued a stay on that order, but an appeals court said Monday full funding must resume.
In the meantime, Pennsylvania distributed some $70 million in SNAP benefits prior to the Jackson ruling, prompting the administration to threaten the state much in the way it threatened grocers who were going to offer discounts.
“To the extent states sent full SNAP payment(s) for November 2025, this is unauthorized,” said the administration statement. “Accordingly, States must immediately undo any steps taken to issue full SNAP benefits,” which then threatened to hold States liable for “overissuances.”
I checked in with my friend Dan Mucy in Fayette County to see if his SNAP money had arrived for November. Unfortunately for him, it was not among the “overissuances.”
“This is just so frustrating, so stressful,” he said. “I’m 68, and to get to this age, hoping to get some peace and dignity, only to made to feel like we have to beg for this. People who’ve been run over by life deserve better than to have to fight the President of the United States for food.”
One in four people in Fayette County are in the SNAP program. Seventy percent of the county voted for Trump, whose casual vilification of SNAP recipients was on full display again Monday on FOX News.
“SNAP is supposed to be, if you’re down and out. You really, really have — that’s what the purpose of it,” he said in a semi-coherent explanation to Laura Ingraham.
“People are going in, they walk in, and they get it automatically now, so the number is many times what it should be,” he continued. “People that need it have to get it. I’m all for it. But people that are able-bodied, can do a job. They leave their job because they figure they can pick this up, it’s easier.
“That’s not the purpose of it. I really puts the country in jeopardy.”
Yeah, that is what’s jeopardizing the country. SNAP benefits.
What Trump really wants
Among the trillions and trillions of things of which Trump is unaware is the fact that most people who get SNAP benefits work. The problem is they work for corporate entities who won’t pay them enough to avoid SNAP.
Some of those same corporate titans can then use the savings to influence government policy, like when July’s Big Beautiful Boondoggle bill extended the tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans, including many of Trump’s favorite oligarchs.
The whole thing really isn’t too complicated. Trump just doesn’t want a country where everyone has the one thing he and his oligarchs will never have: Enough.
Gene Collier is a columnist for the Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and on Bluesky: @genecollier.bsky.social.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “Oh deer, not driving tips.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.