A report on BBC radio last week highlighted the seemingly incongruous importance of comedy to the war in Ukraine, where the distance between a stand-up and a national hero can be less than the length of this sentence.
Similar stories have appeared in multiple media outlets throughout Europe, which ought to make the very idea more plausible than it would appear on its face.
The notion that people are willing and even eager to laugh at a time when Russian bombs are ravaging their cities and shredding their families isn’t the easiest thing to comprehend, especially for anyone with experience in the art form.
As someone who has appeared in comedy clubs coast-to-coast, and even performed in some of them, I find it virtually unimaginable that you can get laughs in a place that is, this month, three years into the invasion that’s killed more than 40,000 Ukrainian fighters and some 12,000 civilians.
Space and people
Real comics, however, most particularly Ukrainian comics, are always able to see what’s possible, despite absolutely everything. “When else,” comic Felix Redka said to The Economist, “would I have the opportunity to do stand-up in a nuclear bomb shelter?”
Redka organized a comedy show in the third week of the Russian occupation of the northeastern city of Sumy. No one should doubt his courage, but he’d probably tell you questions about his sanity were very much in play.
I did stand-up for more than 20 years, long enough to know that its omnipresent X factors are the space it’s in and the people in it. Most nights, the result is primarily audience-driven.
I delivered my “material” almost like a prayer, appropriately enough. The same words in the same exact sequence with the same precise inflections that might bring sustained, appreciative, applause-broken laughter on Friday (emphasis on might) would generate barely a titter on Saturday, if not outright hostility.
The part that’s not about the people you’re talking to and what mood they’re in at that moment is about the space. The importance and the nature of the space, a theater director told me recently, is equal to a character in the show. The space for a comedy show, he would agree, is a very volatile character.
A nuclear bomb shelter is not the optimal space, and a room with the bar in the back is nearly as bad. The people at the bar will not listen to you. A room with a bachelorette party in it is not good. A room that is lit as though for surgery is not good.
Still, any room is superior to no room, which is comedy outdoors, aka certain death. I did it on the stage once at Hartwood Acres in front of thousands. All I heard was the dogs. They howled.
Budget psychotherapy
Any or all of the audience/space variables can scuttle whatever it is you think you’re being funny about, which remains the key exigency: What are you going to say, much less say to a bunker of Ukrainian war widows?
“I live on the outskirts (of Kyiv), but the nukes will hit the central parts,” goes a bit that popular Ukrainian comic Nastya Zukhvala shared with the BBC. “Before the fallout reaches me, it will have to make two changes on the metro.
“More realistically, I’ll get killed by Iranian Shahed drones. The sad thing is — did you hear the noise they make? The sound is very demotivating, like the cheapest kind of death.”
You can bet that Nastya would tell you she’s heard that land five different ways, but the point is the courage, both hers and the audience’s. One stand-up described comedy in Ukraine as the budget version of psychotherapy. Another as a tool to “make things look less catastrophic. To stay optimistic or even sane, we’ve got no other choice.”
Comedy has worked there, and elsewhere, in moments of extreme national stress. When Saturday Night Live first returned after 9/11, then Mayor Rudy Giuliani was in the audience with dozens of New York firefighters. Invited on stage by producer Lorne Michaels, who thanked them and asked, “Can we be funny?” Giuliani said, “Why start now?”
The truth-teller
And there was laughter, which, if not the best medicine, is like nothing else.
In Ukraine, laughter has long helped to construct the political fabric. President Volodymyr Zelensky was a star with the sketch comedy group Kyartal 95 when he was elected in 2019. He knows how the art form works, even in world’s worst rooms.
“The Comic has become the truth teller, the person who pulls back the curtain,” the American comic and writer Keegan-Michael Key once said. “Some people can be moved by a wonderful piece of rhetoric, some by a stirring speech. But everybody can be moved by something that makes them laugh. Everybody.”
Gene Collier’s previous column was “Trump’s incalculable damage to science and health.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.