Not that most Americans have actually paid it a lot of attention, but our judicial system has begun melting away under the baleful glare of Donald J. Trump. If you’ve been putting off any illegal activities, this might be your moment.
Anything from holding up a convenience store to stealing classified documents or even planning a violent coup is apparently within your range of options here at the butt end of 2023, and if you meet any legal resistance, just tell ‘em you’re running for president and you’re good to go.
A river of venom
Judges who’ve been reduced to trafficking in pretzel logic while trying to stay afloat in Trump’s river of venom now include Colorado’s state District Judge Sarah B. Wallace, who on Friday essentially ruled that Trump cannot be disqualified from running for office by the 14th Amendment, even though he did engage in insurrection, because it’s not clear that the Amendment that keeps insurrectionists from running for office applies to the office of the president.
Wow, and all this time you thought that President of the United States was not only a government office job, but in fact the job of running the highest office in the land.
No, no; hold on there, Constitution breath.
Read More
Wallace’s ruling is tangled up in the oath of office, it turns out, and there’s one oath for the president and one for various other government operatives. The oath the president takes is to “preserve, protect, and defend” the Constitution, while the other one says “support” the Constitution.
Trump’s legal argument on this matter, handled by some of his few remaining unindicted lawyers, was that while he promised to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution, he did not promise to support it. I wish I were making that up.
How do you not support something you promised to preserve, protect, and defend? The only explanation I can generate goes back to Murphy, the late belligerent Airedale who lived here some years ago. I guess, technically, I preserved, protected, and even defended the Murph against his frequent detractors. But I did not always support him. He was a royal pain.
Obviously, that could never been confused with a legal argument, as it’s nothing but a preposterous rhetorical sideshow.
The first scary part
For a legal interpretation, you might better rely on, say, Laurence H. Tribe, professor of constitutional law emeritus, Harvard, who explained the following to CNN: “The whole rule of law would be shredded if we said that the president is above the law because his oath, because of its wording, exempts him from the most fundamental requirement of law: that when your term is up you leave.”
Then the scary part: “It’s only dictators who stay . . . that’s why the fate of the United States and democracies around the world is at stake in whether Donald Trump is allowed ever again to take the oath to support the Constitution. He’s clearly not going to mean it. That's the scary part.”
But there’s a scary part way out in front of that scary part, and it’s that judges themselves are scared to so much as fully enforce a gag order on Trump, let alone acknowledge that anyone else who bad-mouthed a judge or court personnel or said things that could poison a jury pool would be in jail.
John Dean, the former White House Counsel Watergate witness, went straight to the end of his wits over this ongoing circus on Monday. “I do not understand why an election campaign for the presidency is receiving special consideration for a person being held responsible for criminal behavior,” he tweeted.
“Donald Trump has turned the rule of law in the United States upside down, and it is stunning that federal circuit court judges are buying into his remarkable con! The hearing today on the degree these judges will allow Trump to trash another institution bordered on pure farce. For heaven sakes, hold this man responsible for his aberrant and bullying behavior before he further destroys our country. Enough is enough is enough!”
You know things are serious when the old “enough is enough” declaration gets an extra “enough.”
Arguments over gag orders, limited gag orders, appeals of gag orders, they all prove one thing. It’s that the judges in question, Arthur Engoron in New York, Tanya Chutkan in Washington, D.C., and now Judge Wallace in Colorado, are just not willing to drop the hammer.
The really scary thing
And that’s the really, really scary thing, right? Maybe we’ve passed the point of no return, where Trump has simply frightened the legal system’s top officers into submission.
The Colorado ruling has been appealed to the state Supreme Court, where I’m guessing enough is enough is enough just won’t be enough.
Gene Collier is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: gcollier@post-gazette.com and @genecollier. His previous column was “History's indelible menace.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.