This is the final editorial from the Post-Gazette Editorial Board. As a nonprofit organization, the Venetoulis Institute for Local Journalism, which has purchased the Post-Gazette’s assets from Block Communications, Inc., does not support or oppose public policies or candidates for public office.
Of course, this board believes in the value of the classic editorial function of a newspaper, or else we wouldn’t be in this business. At the same time, we understand the position of the Venetoulis Institute, and are excited to see how the organization stewards this essential institution for (we hope) many years to come.
Indeed, we can be nothing but grateful to the Institute for saving this newspaper from closure or, at least as bad, being strip-mined by a profit-obsessed hedge fund.
Similarly, we are grateful for the stewardship of Block Communications and the Block family for nearly a century of journalism in Pittsburgh. This newspaper remained so much more robust than those in comparable cities because the family loves and values independent local journalism — and they lost hundreds of millions of dollars in the process. The family’s last act, to hand off the Post-Gazette at a lower price to a responsible nonprofit rather than to a hedge fund, demonstrates their good will to this institution and to Pittsburgh.
As the curtain drops on this act for the Post-Gazette, we thought we’d pull another curtain back. Editorials and editorial boards are, by design, a little mysterious. So let us tell you how we’ve operated, at least for the past few years.
Behind the curtain
These words are being typed by editorial page editor Brandon McGinley, who has drafted the vast majority (well over 1,000, according to our system) of Post-Gazette editorials since October 2021. That was when he joined the paper as associate editor. No member of the current board was with the Post-Gazette before this date.
The other two members of the team are deputy editor David Mills, who joined the paper in April 2022, and columnist and InReview editor Adriana E. Ramírez, who joined in November 2022. Every editorial is read and approved (and sometimes substantially revised) by Mills and Ramírez. Thus, the editorials reflect our shared values, while rarely being written exactly as each of us would prefer.
We must also express our gratitude to other members of our team from the past four-and-a-half years: former editorial page editor Jeffery Gerritt and former associate editor Rebecca Spiess, who was part of our 2023 Pulitzer finalist effort.
This is quite small for a traditional editorial board, but we believe it allowed us to respond nimbly to the news. It also allowed us to chase stories independently, including breaking news on the editorial page — a sensibility for which Gerritt deserves much credit. While most news should and must remain free of commentary, we came to believe that the ability to judiciously inject commentary into our reporting, in articles marked clearly as opinion, allowed us to contextualize and enliven our work.
Indeed, while “editorial boards” are rarely known for jollity, we can all say that we had great fun.
Important work
As opinion journalism at the Post-Gazette transitions to a new phase, let us briefly address its future more broadly.
We believe in the importance of informed commentary to a healthy political community. Not every institution has to embrace this in the same way, or at all, but as a whole, airing a diversity of perspectives is essential to improving the mutual understanding necessary to democratic cultures.
Social media is not a substitute. Unfortunately, constant access to millions of opinions (Everyone’s got one!) has, for too many people, made legitimate opinion journalism seem superfluous. We suspect that opinion overload has also contributed — among other factors, such as the injection of commentary into news coverage — to a crisis of credibility in opinion journalism.
We recognized early on that the traditional editorial model, which depended on trust in the authority of a nameless faceless “board” of experts and clever people, had more or less run its course. Whatever credibility we had was never going to depend on who we were, but would have to be earned based on what we brought to the table.
That’s why our goal was to bring something new to every editorial we wrote. At its best, that meant original reporting and breaking big news on the editorial page. Of course that was impossible to do several times a week, but as far as possible we tried to include an argument, a fact, an idea that you hadn’t heard before, and would be unlikely to find elsewhere.
This is also why we generally kept the focus local: We could hardly bring something new to you about Donald Trump or Joe Biden, but we could about Ed Gainey or Sara Innamorato or property assessments or the city budget. While we did sometimes lapse into more traditional pontification — even then we tried to say something new and interesting every time — we knew our most influential work would always regard the people and institutions we knew best, closest to home.
Indeed, this is where we believe the future of opinion journalism will be. While there will always be a place for the essay on ideas, curated opinion journalism — if it is to distinguish itself from everyone-has-one social media opinionating — will depend for its credibility on accurate, authoritative original reporting. This kind of work has enduring value to democratic societies.
Goodbye
The Post-Gazette Editorial Board’s part in this story, however, ends today.
Thank you for supporting us and this newspaper and this city, which all of us love dearly. Thank you for bringing us up on your phones and for bringing us into your homes. Thank you for your notes of appreciation and your expressions of outrage. Thank you for holding us accountable as we tried to hold the powerful accountable.
“With malice toward none, with charity for all” — goodbye.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.