Pittsburgh’s renters, especially students, have long operated at an information deficit. Many have to sign leases on rental units quickly in order to secure housing, occasionally sight-unseen, which makes finding information on possible landlords crucial. But few have the resources to find it.

A new website created by University of Pittsburgh students might help fill that gap. “Rate Yinz Landlord” allows tenants to anonymously review their landlords, giving their potential replacements a heads-up on what to expect.

As its creators note, many renters endure poor conditions, including delayed repairs and far more serious issues, yet don’t feel empowered to complain in a way that could actually improve the rental system for others.

“Rate Yinz Landlord” borrows its name and model from a popular professor-rating website, something students will find familiar. This isn’t a coincidence: Many of those who face the most daunting challenges as renters are students, especially in the crowded South Oakland neighborhood where lodging is notoriously hit-or-miss, and sometimes dangerous.

Advertise with us

“Rate My Professor” helps students make informed choices about their course selections. “Rate Yinz Landlord” is meant to help renters make informed choices about housing.

This partly fills a need for landlord accountability in Pittsburgh that city government has found very difficult to fill itself. The saga of the city’s attempts to create a rental registry has now dragged on for over a decade. City Council has made repeated attempts to develop a registration-and-inspection regime, but every time landlord associations have successfully challenged the ordinances’ legality.

As of today, the city remains enjoined from enforcing its most recent rental registry legislation.

We completely understand, therefore, the impetus behind the anonymous landlord rating website. But that doesn’t mean it’s a perfect solution.

The landlord-rating site has the potential to replicate a core weakness of its professor-rating counterpart: Those most motivated to post are those with grievances, not those with fair or good experiences. Indeed, our own quick perusal of the site reveals that the vast majority of reviews are extremely negative.

Advertise with us

Now that could, and to some degree does, reflect the poor state of property management in Pittsburgh and elsewhere. But it also reflects a structure that will always elevate grievances over the experiences of the typical renter.

A website meant to illuminate the situation could also distort it. One simple improvement would be to give landlords a chance to speak for themselves. While this would give some landlords a chance to hide real problems with their properties, readers will still be able to evaluate their claims against their tenants’ reports. Among other benefits of a structured response system, it could help users distinguish between isolated conflicts and true neglect.

It would also put landlords’ own words on display. Poorly reasoned or dismissive responses can be as informative as the complaints themselves. Transparency cuts both ways.

This entire discussion, though, only highlights the need for a durable rental-registry solution for Pittsburgh and its surrounding communities. The best way to ensure that all housing reaches a baseline of livability is for a public authority to enforce standards.

A functioning rental registry wouldn’t completely remove the need for something like “Rate Yinz Landord” — no public registry would include information about management’s responsiveness to communication, for instance — but it would ensure renters aren’t flying blind, or relying only on rumor and intuition, when picking a place to call home.

When it comes to navigating Pittsburgh housing, knowledge is power.