Taxpayer-funded legal expenses incurred by Harrisburg legislators, uncovered and described by PennLive this week, raise numerous questions about transparency and accountability in the state capital — but above all they point to a culture of casually relying on taxpayers as if they’re an inexhaustible piggy bank for politicians.

The fees amounts to nearly $10 million in just the last three years. They included everything from partisan (though arguably legitimate) legislative litigation to defending against harassment claims to, ironically, fighting requests for public records.

The most egregious example is certainly that of state Sen. Doug Mastriano, R-Franklin, the erstwhile gubernatorial candidate who spent Jan. 6, 2021, as part of the crowd that surged toward the U.S. Capitol. Pennsylvania taxpayers footed the bill for nearly $400,000 in criminal defense fees regarding his participation in the events of that day. Mastriano was never charged.

But the purpose of the government reimbursing legislators’ legal fees is to ensure they have sufficient representation for actions undertaken in their official capacities. It would hamstring elected officials if they had to worry about the costs of litigation for performing the duties the public entrusted to them.

Advertise with us

This raises the obvious question: What business of the people of Pennsylvania, or of his district, was Mastriano conducting in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 6, 2021? However else one might describe the crowds in the capital that day, few could disagree that it was a partisan political gathering.

Somebody has to answer this question. Neither Mastriano nor Senate Chief Clerk Russell Faber, who decides what counts as a “legislative purpose” in these matters, responded to PennLive’s requests for comment. Lacking an answer, the Mastriano reimbursement sets a dangerous precedent of Pennsylvania taxpayers subsidizing the personal political activities of legislators, which should be covered by their respective parties.

The taxpayer subsidization doesn’t end with Mastriano, however. One particularly ironic use of taxpayer dollars, for instance, was fighting requests to make government documents available to taxpayers themselves: That is, Pennsylvanians are paying politicians to keep themselves in the dark. PennLive found over $140,000 in legal fees for this purpose over the past three years.

Among the most troubling discoveries, though, were the hundreds of thousands of dollars spent for unclear purposes, with paperwork vaguely describing “individuals in litigation in federal and state court,” according to PennLive. These descriptions are clearly meant to skirt reporting rules and hide the nature of the litigation in question.

Altogether, the report sketches a portrait of a system where taxpayer reimbursement for legal expenses is essentially taken for granted. While public funds can be appropriately used to help public officials perform their public duties, they mustn’t become a means of subsidizing political activity or bad behavior.

Advertise with us

One way to potentially cut down on the cost of these legal services, ensure they are being used for properly official purposes and to avoid conflicts of interest with law firms that contribute generously to political campaigns would be to bring more litigators in house. This is far from a panacea and could raise problems of its own, such as a legal arms race between the parties and the chambers.

Above all, we’d like to see Gov. Josh Shapiro become a champion of transparency who advocates for the legislature to tighten the rules on itself (and on the executive, for that matter). The chambers won’t do it themselves, so an outside force of some kind will be needed.

Only this will slowly reform the culture of reliance on taxpayers that’s endemic in Harrisburg.