The early days of spring are the end of the pruning season, when gardeners trim the branches from their plants to make room for, and to encourage, new growth. How fitting, then, that the City of Pittsburgh has undertaken a major blitz of demolitions of blighted properties during this season.

The city’s efforts, concentrated in the Hilltop neighborhoods of the South Hills in coordination with Councilman Bob Charland, should mark a turning point for its relationship with blight, which is choking off hope and growth in neighborhoods that desperately need both.

Of particular note is the property highlighted by the city’s (and Mayor Corey O’Connor’s) social media account on Monday: 440 Parkwood Road in the Mt. Oliver neighborhood (which is distinct from Mt. Oliver Borough). This dilapidated home on the edge of a part of the city seemingly about to be reclaimed by nature is owned by, yes, the City of Pittsburgh.

In a groundbreaking report in December 2024, the Post-Gazette reported that the city owns over 10,000 vacant structures and lots, which had accumulated 1,300 code violations over the previous four-and-a-half years. In other words, the worst absentee property owner, responsible for thousands of blighted properties that hold back neighborhoods (especially Black-majority neighborhoods) across Pittsburgh, is the city itself.

Advertise with us

As Pittsburgh emptied out during and after post-industrial economic collapse, one strategy city government deployed was to buy up empty homes, on the theory that its stewardship couldn’t be worse than none at all — such as when a homeowner died and no inheritor took responsibility. Then the city could find a new owner to get the property back in shape and on the tax rolls.

But this was deeply short-sighted: Most of the properties in question had serious tax liens, and required tens or (more likely) hundreds of thousands of dollars in work to become livable. Meanwhile the process to actually acquire a property from the city was a bureaucratic nightmare. The city, of course, lacked the capacity to manage these properties itself, so they degraded further — collecting code violations the city couldn’t enforce against itself.

Pittsburgh has been slow to acknowledge and to remedy this error. The Land Bank, after several years of wrangling, has finally gotten in shape to move some city-owned properties back to the market by clearing old tax liens. But it still needs more help, in terms of staff and funding, to really make a dent.

Demolition, on the other hand, is a tried and true way to accelerate the process of neighborhood renewal, or at least to arrest the process of decline. Squalid structures depress property values and overall livability by being havens for vermin and criminal activity, but perhaps most of all simply by being eyesores that discourage existing residents and dissuade new ones. In cites from Detroit to Baltimore, there is strong evidence that blight-demolition is a necessary prerequisite to neighborhood renewal.

Razing privately owned structures requires an onerous process, so the city should focus its efforts on its own properties.

Advertise with us

Unfortunately, Pittsburgh missed a tremendous opportunity to radically accelerate its demolition program: federal pandemic relief finds. Despite having hundreds of millions of dollars at its disposal, the city used only $7 million for addressing blight, which funded about 140 demolitions. And now Pittsburgh is experiencing a major cash crunch.

But targeted blight remediation through demolitions is one of the most efficient ways to use the money the city has. We hope the Hilltop demolition derby is followed by others around the city. Just as with pruning, one of the best ways to facilitate new life is to clear away what is long dead.