After a state Supreme Court ruling this week, Pennsylvania can finally be removed from the small list of states that unfairly impose a mandatory sentence of life without parole for felony murder, also known as second-degree murder. This decision will liberate the state’s courts to take into account the circumstances under which a crime occurred when applying a sentence.

Two years ago, when the justices took up Commonwealth v. Lee, we implored the General Assembly to reform the state’s felony murder law. It did not do so, and so the court has now revamped Pennsylvania’s unjust-punishments doctrine, with potentially wide-ranging consequences.

Chief Justice Debra Todd wrote the opinion for the court, which was joined by Justices Christine Donohue, Kevin M. Dougherty, David N. Wecht and Daniel D. McCaffrey, finding that mandatory life without parole violates the state constitution (but, interestingly, not the U.S. Constitution). Justice Sallie Updyke Mundy wrote concurring in the decision, while Justice P. Kevin Brobson filed an opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part.

Mandating a sentence as severe as life without parole — which could also be called death by incarceration — completely flattens the extremely diverse category of felony murder, which includes everything from violent-but-not-deadly assaults to driving a getaway car after a botched robbery. The result is grossly unjust sentences, with little to no deterrent effect on crime. Pennsylvania is a better state without this draconian compulsory sentence.

Advertise with us

Law and justice

There are over 1,000 people incarcerated in Pennsylvania prisons under the state’s mandatory life without parole rule for felony murder. But this crime includes many different actions, with many different degrees of culpability.

The case that triggered the court’s ruling came out of the Elliott neighborhood of Pittsburgh. In 2014, Derek Lee participated in a violent home invasion and robbery, but did not fire the gun that killed Leonard Butler. This is classic felony murder: Lee committed a felony that resulted in the death of an innocent person, even though he neither committed the homicide or intended to kill.

This crime was on the more egregious side of felony murder, and likely would have resulted in a very long sentence even if life without parole weren’t mandated. This is an essential point: Defendants convicted of felony murder can still get life sentences after this decision; the only change is that judges don’t have to impose this sentence.

Many other felony murder convictions involve far less serious crimes. For instance, the first “juvenile lifer” released in Pennsylvania after the U.S. Supreme Court invalidated mandatory life sentences for minors was Jeffrey Cristina. At 17 years old in the 1970s, he served as a lookout for a Lawrenceville gang leader who robbed an elderly resident, resulting in his death. That action — wrong and criminal, but quite different from violent assaults or other active participation in a murder — was treated the same as any other felony murder under state law, until this week.

Here’s how the Editorial Board put it two years ago: “Lookouts have been imprisoned longer than their killer counterparts; burglars whose elderly victims later died of heart attacks have been treated as intentional murderers; and those who were unwilling witnesses to killings by family members have been treated more harshly than the killers themselves.”

Advertise with us

Allowing for sentences that truly fit the crime isn’t coddling criminals; it’s ensuring real justice is done.

Novel interpretation

Justice Todd’s opinion also broke new ground in the interpretation of Pennsylvania’s constitution. Until now, Article 1, Section 13 of the state charter was interpreted to include the exact same punishments as the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which reads in part: “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”

Pennsylvania’s clause uses the exact same language, except for dropping “and unusual.” But, the court argued, the commonwealth has a distinctive legal history from the federal government. Further, other state courts with similar constitutional clauses have interpreted those clauses more broadly than the Supreme Court has interpreted the Eighth Amendment. The decision may open the door to ruling out other punishments under the state constitution that are permitted under the federal.

Pennsylvania was an outlier among the states with its narrowly construed unjust-punishments clause. And certainly its felony murder law was an outlier: Depending on precise legal definitions, the state was one of as many as ten or as few as two (Louisiana) with such a strict sentencing rule.

After this week, the commonwealth has returned to the mainstream of criminal justice. More importantly, it removes a major distortion to the provision of real justice in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Restored hope

The state’s compulsory life without parole law didn’t just affect those charged with felony murder: It served as a cudgel prosecutors could use to threaten defendants in order to squeeze information or confessions — or to get them to plead to other charges, beyond the scope of their crimes.

But perhaps worst of all, mandatory life without parole completely excludes the possibility of rehabilitation for an extremely wide variety of crimes. Are there felony murder cases for which this punishment might be proportionate and appropriate? Certainly. But the idea that all defendants convicted of felony murder are beyond rehabilitation is simply untrue, and cruel.

“All other crimes,” we wrote two years ago, “including others involving homicide, are judged through the lens of statutory minimums, the details of the case and the history of the offender. This system also takes into account the most important voices: the families and loved ones of victims. Yet in Pennsylvania, none of this matters in felony murder cases.”

That, happily, is no longer the case. And Pennsylvania’s justice system is better for it.