This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city, and southwestern Pennsylvania more generally, during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.
Governmental fragmentation is one of the most pressing problems facing the Pittsburgh region. In a previous editorial, we covered the concept of a merger between the City of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County, in which the operations of the city would be taken over by the combined government, while some operations of the county’s other 129 municipalities would become part of a city-county “general services unit.”
This would be among the more drastic solutions to the fragmentation problem. A more measured approach, which has already been proposed in Harrisburg, is municipal disincorporation.
History of fragmentation
Pennsylvania is unusual in that every square inch of the commonwealth is incorporated into a municipality: city, borough, township or (in one case only) town. This means that every resident is subject to four levels of government — federal, state, county, municipal — and five levels of taxation — add in school districts.
More typical arrangements elsewhere leave large tracts of land “unincorporated,” which means that their lowest level of government is the county or county-equivalent. These areas, typically sparsely populated, would struggle to generate the resources needed for the efficient administration of local government, so the county provides services. The residents pay a higher county tax rate than their neighbors in incorporated zones, who pay municipal taxes.
Allegheny County’s fragmented governance is the result of chipping away at the county’s early townships, some of which, such as Baldwin in the South Hills, population 1,984, still exist as rumps. As communities developed organically, especially in the valleys of the rivers and creeks, their inhabitants sought the ability to control their own affairs, since the needs of these denser settlements were quite different from the largely unpeopled surroundings.
Thus the region ended up with Bellevue, Avalon, Ben Avon, Emsworth, Glenfield (population 212), Haysville (population 81), Glen Osborne, Sewickley, Edgeworth and Leetsdale along just the right bank of a 10-mile stretch of the Ohio River. And this doesn’t even mention Ben Avon Heights, Sewickley Heights, Sewickley Hills, Bell Acres and the townships of Neville, Ohio, Kilbuck, Aleppo and Leet.
The Monongahela, Turtle Creek and Youghiogheny valleys are even more complex, too much so to list the municipalities in any kind of rational order.
Some of these boroughs were always tiny, like Haysville, which has never had more than 200 people. Glassport in the Mon Valley, on the other hand, once had nearly 10,000 people and its own semi-pro football team. Now it’s at around 4,500 people. The conditions that supported fragmentation no longer exist, and they aren’t coming back.
A deliberate, democratic process
The gentlest way to reverse fragmentation, however, is not possible under current state law. That’s the voluntary dissolution of a municipal government, and it’s the subject of legislation sponsored by Allegheny County members of the House (Rep. Emily Kinkead, D-Bellevue) and Senate (Sen. Nick Pisciottano, D-West Mifflin).
If either bill were to pass, the voters of a financially struggling municipality would have the ability to vote on whether to dissolve their local government, handing over municipal responsibilities to the county. That decision would have to be ratified by County Council, which would set tax rates for newly unincorporated districts.
Dissolution would not erase the municipality forever: Each unincorporated area would remain a distinct “district” within the county, and each district’s voters would retain the right to reconstitute its municipal government — or to merge with an adjacent municipality.
Not to pick on the tiniest borough too much, but we’ll use Haysville as an example. Its governing body, a five-member council, could pass a non-binding resolution expressing interest in dissolution, triggering a negotiation with the county on a transition plan. Once the plan is completed, the council would have to adopt it as an ordinance. This would trigger a referendum, in which all the few dozen voters of the borough can participate. If the referendum were to pass, Haysville Borough would cease to exist, and the Haysville county services district would come into being.
If the people of Haysville eventually found this unsatisfactory, they could petition for a new vote on whether to become a borough again, or to merge with a neighbor such as Aleppo Township, whose voters would also have to agree to it.
All in all, this would be a very slow, very deliberative process.
Too many, too small
The fundamental problem is that too many of Allegheny County’s municipalities are too small to govern themselves effectively. The literature on local governance confirms common sense and experience in the Pittsburgh region: Smaller communities cost much more per person to govern. Services generally get more efficient, according to a Rutgers University review of the scholarship, up to around 25,000 people — roughly the minimum size for an ideal local government.
Of the 129 non-Pittsburgh local governments in Allegheny County, only 10 reach this threshold. Meanwhile, 14 have fewer than 1,000 people. This is not sustainable for the region, and it’s squeezing the taxpayers of largely less affluent communities.
Writing municipal dissolution into state law would give these communities an opportunity they are currently denied: the opportunity to try something different.
Whereas a city-county merger would significantly change governance across the county in one swoop, the dissolution process would be piecemeal and tailored to individual communities. For this reason it would be slow — possibly too slow for a region that needed government reform yesterday. But, we suspect, as success stories developed, it’s a process that might accelerate quickly as communities’ fears of losing control evaporate when confronted with cost savings and reduced burdens.
We urge the state legislature to take up and pass a municipal dissolution bill. It can’t hurt to give the voters a chance to try a new way of governing themselves.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.