Multimillion-dollar donations from two of Pittsburgh’s top employers, UPMC and PNC Bank, are welcome and necessary investments in the city’s shabby vehicle fleet. We hope and expect that they represent not just one-time gifts, but the beginning of a new era of cooperation between Pittsburgh’s public and private sectors — including permanent annual commitments from the city’s biggest nonprofit institutions.
Last weekend’s record snowstorm proved what everyone from this board to City Controller Rachael Heisler to new Mayor Corey O’Connor had warned: Pittsburgh’s ability to provide basic municipal services has been dangerously diminished due to many years of negligence and malinvestment, particularly in its vehicles.
Monday morning’s announcement that about 40% of the city’s snow-removal fleet, 37 vehicles, had broken down overnight produced shock and jeers, as an initially robust snow response was hobbled. But it was also utterly predictable, as the city’s aging fleet limped into this nearly unprecedented mix of snow and cold, and was never going to emerge unscathed.
UPMC’s $10 million contribution, followed the next day by $2 million from the PNC Foundation, will buy 50 new public works vehicles, nine ambulances and one “rescue vehicle.” The UPMC gift will also fund a similar number of EMS vehicles in 2027.
To be clear, this is a start, not a solution. Pittsburgh’s fleet will not be in a sustainably tolerable condition until the city makes substantial annual investments in effective maintenance and timely replacements — supplemented by consistent contributions from the city’s biggest institutions, especially those free from most property taxation, who benefit tremendously from robust city services.
The spirit of cooperation that swept into City Hall with Corey O’Connor offers the best hope in a long time that this kind of collaborative arrangement could, finally, come to pass.
Fixing the fleet
The condition of Pittsburgh’s fleet is a slow-motion disaster. About half of the roughly 1,200 active vehicles and pieces of equipment are older than their life expectancies, including nearly 60% of Department of Public Works (DPW) trucks. The city should have entered winter with well over 100 vehicles prepared to plow snow and spread salt, but has only had (at the very best) around 90 ready to go.
And at any time, dozens are on the edge of being unusable. The resulting service deficits aren’t just annoying but dangerous.
The Gainey administration estimated the cost to get 80% of the fleet consistently within its cost-effective lifespan at $27.6 million a year for half a decade. To get it to 100%, that balloons to over $41 million.
But an analysis by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board showed that the Ravenstahl, Peduto and Gainey administrations collectively spent, in inflation-adjusted dollars, an average of under $10 million per year on new vehicles, with Gainey the lowest at $7.4 million. In other words, this is a long-term problem resistant to short-term solutions — particularly because the city’s structural deficit (even after a significant tax increase) limits its ability to boost fleet investments on its own.
Breaking the ice
Enter UPMC, bugbear of the Gainey administration, which broke the ice on Thursday by announcing its $10 million commitment. It’s a gesture that, besides benefitting the city in itself, put the rest of Pittsburgh’s institutions on notice: Pitch in or get left behind.
The healthcare giant’s CEO, Leslie Davis, implied as much in her statement at the press conference with O’Connor: “We hope this investment will serve as a catalyst for broader collaboration among the other civic, nonprofit and private-sector partners who share our dedication to the well-being of Pittsburgh’s communities.”
PNC followed the next day with a $2 million gift of its own through its foundation, potentially firing the starting pistol among for-profit corporations.
A flurry of private giving to mitigate the city’s public troubles in the first weeks of the O’Connor administration would be a significant victory — especially after former Mayor Ed Gainey campaigned on making UPMC and others pay their “fair share” and got nothing for four years. Indeed, if several other nonprofits and for-profits chip in under peer pressure, it might be enough to stabilize the fleet, something we only thought would be possible by floating an expensive bond.
Beginning, not end
But it can’t be the end of the story. UPMC’s $10 million gift, which is spread out over two years, is much less than even the most low-ball estimates for what the massive conglomerate would contribute in a true payments-in-lieu-of-taxes (PILOT) program.
If UPMC were to ride the goodwill from this moment to avoid future contributions, this gift will be remembered not as an act of generosity (and as a victory for O’Connor), but as a sneaky discount ticket (and as a capitulation by O’Connor). The same goes for anyone else who pitches in during the coming days and weeks — including PNC and other corporations, which have the resources to be ongoing partners, not just one-time contributors.
In its public statements this week, UPMC indicated that it remains open to a more permanent arrangement along the usual lines — that is, as long as other institutions pitch in proportionately. O’Connor must hold them to that commitment. This $10 million should be seen as the beginning of a new era of engagement not just with city government but among private-sector institutions, and not as the final and full satisfaction of civic responsibilities.
In this regard, we renew our proposal for the city to develop a vehicle trust fund to which institutions like UPMC can contribute annually. These institutions benefit directly from the city services to which the fleet is essential; it’s a natural place for them to chip in.
City Councilwoman Barb Warwick has recently introduced legislation that would create a fleet fund, to ensure a minimum of $20 million annual city investment. O’Connor and City Council should explore whether this proposal could be adapted into a vessel for private-sector investments in city vehicles.
If this is a turning point, and not an ending point, it could be one of the most important moments in Pittsburgh’s recent history.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.