There’s a weird wrinkle in Pittsburgh’s current budget crunch, which needs to be corrected to keep the city’s finances on the straight-and-narrow going forward: The budget can be officially “balanced,” when it isn’t truly balanced. Thanks to this wrinkle, the city is hemorrhaging over $30 million a year.

That’s because Pittsburgh reckons whether its operating budget passes muster before accounting for transfers to certain other government funds. These transfers are justified as capital expenditures — typically spending on long-term or one-time projects — separate from the day-to-day operations of the city. The problem is that some of them aren’t really capital expenses.

It’s a neat trick that has allowed mayors and council members to earmark funding for special purposes without making it more difficult to make budget.

Bad math

Here’s an example from the 2025 budget. The city projected about $669 million in revenues and $666 million in expenses, which include salaries and other employment expenses, pension obligations, everyday operating costs (such as maintenance of city vehicles, vendor contracts and so on) and debt service. That left the budgeted “operating result” at about $3 million, fulfilling the obligation under the Home Rule Charter to balance the budget.

Advertise with us

A little tight, but not so bad. But again, it isn’t actually balanced. It does not account for four major expenses: $12.7 million for capital projects, $10 million for the Housing Opportunity Fund, $2.5 million to pay off 2023’s 25-year “affordable housing bond” and $10 million for the Stop the Violence Fund.

That $35 million in required spending means that the 2025 “balanced” budget will require taking $32 million out of city’s reserves. (The final cost will actually end up being $35 million or more.) That’s not a truly balanced budget.

This weird wrinkle would work — if city leaders were careful about ensuring the official operating result left enough for these transfers to take place. Instead, under the Gainey administration, they’ve become an annual drain on the city’s reserves.

In fact, Mayor Ed Gainey’s 2026 budget projects the city dipping into its reserves every year through 2030, despite every year being nominally “balanced.”

Hiding the ball

Some of the post-operating-result transfers are more defensible than others. For instance, the annual “PAYGO” transfer, short for “pay-as-you-go,” is straightforwardly for capital expenditures.

Advertise with us

The Housing Opportunity Fund (HOF) and the housing bond are both transfers to the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA), which are typically treated as capital expenditures, as well. The programs funded by the HOF would otherwise be considered PAYGO: The existence of the fund, and the statutorily required $10 million transfer, ensures that a substantial amount of capital spending goes to affordable housing programs each year.

The bond transfer is trickier. The city used the URA to take out the debt, rather than doing so itself, which allows it to justify the $2.5 million annual transfer as a “capital expense” to the URA, rather than debt service. This should be folded into the debt service portion of the operating budget.

The least defensible transfer is the $10 million for the Stop the Violence Fund (STV), much of which is used for day-to-day city operations, including salaries and employee benefits. The 2025 budget set aside over $6 million from STV to fund the Office of Community Health and Safety, clearly an operating expense. Treating the STV transfer as a capital expense hides the ball, allowing the city to skirt its balanced budget requirement.

Honest accounting

We understand that the precise definition of “balanced budget,” and of which expenses can be accounted for after the operating result, is being considered by the city’s Law Department.

Regardless of its findings, the city must pass into law a more precise definition, which would forbid using agency bond issuances and trust funds to hide operating expenditures. Only true capital expenses should be reckoned beyond the scope of the balanced budget requirement.

Advertise with us

In practice, that would mean moving at least $12.5 million in expenses back into the operating budget, forcing city leaders to make hard choices based on honest numbers.

Always, the city should err on the side of policies that encourage fiscal restraint. The consequences of failing to do so are apparent in this month’s scramble to get Pittsburgh back on firm financial footing.