Nearly a decade after it was first conceived, the biggest residential-and-retail development project in Pittsburgh since the SouthSide Works is officially under construction. Esplanade will transform the Ohio riverfront at the south end of the Chateau neighborhood, bringing over 800 units of housing, restaurants, an amphitheater, a marina and a Ferris wheel with views of the Point and the Golden Triangle.
It’s the kind of ambitious project that could be remembered, in the years and decades to come, as a symbol and catalyst of a resurgent city. Or it could seen as an absurd extravagance, a white elephant that sits uneasily in the urban fabric, burdens city infrastructure and primarily serves to highlight its overall stagnation.
We are optimistic for the former outcome. But Esplanade won’t succeed on its own: Property development doesn’t spark economic growth all by itself. There must be enough people with enough money to live in the buildings, to dine in the restaurants, to shop in the stores and to buy tickets to the attractions — without cannibalizing existing amenities. In other words, while exceptional property developments can spark excitement and attract investment, ultimately their success depends on existing within a dynamic urban and regional economy, which requires a public sector that embraces the private sector.
Specifically, there are three conditions we believe will be necessary to ensure Esplanade’s success: a renewed commitment among public officials to job creation; a more efficient city permitting system; and kitting the development fully into the city’s transportation network, specifically by extending the T light rail system.
Building toward growth
The question that has haunted Esplanade from the beginning is this: Does Pittsburgh need it? Or, put another way: Can Pittsburgh’s economy absorb it — without merely draining people and resources from other parts of the city?
This is the quandary faced by industrial cities with stagnant populations: Economic development becomes a zero-sum game. The North Shore’s and the Strip District’s gains, for instance, are clearly at least partially Downtown’s losses. Will Esplanade steal from Lawrenceville, or the Strip, or the South Side to fill its buildings and coffers?
This is not a line of reasoning that growing cities and regions must consider, at least to the same degree that stagnant ones do. Worse, this kind of stagnancy tends to manifest in political rancor and dysfunction, because stakeholders are competing over a fixed market and basket of resources: Every benefit is someone else’s deficit.
The way to ensure that Esplanade doesn’t merely drain people and money and activity from one part of the city to another is to commit to a job-attraction and -retention strategy that ensures there are enough people and enough resources to go around. Getting Esplanade across the finish line, therefore, isn’t the culmination of an economic development strategy. Rather, it triggers the necessity of developing a more dynamic economy within which Esplanade will make sense for decades to come.
That must include, among other strategies, ensuring that Pittsburgh’s city government doesn’t function as an impediment to job creation.
Cutting red tape
At the Esplanade groundbreaking, Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor pledged to move permits efficiently through the city’s byzantine system. Following through on that promise — not just for Esplanade, but for everything from affordable housing developments to backyard sheds — will be one of the most important tasks he can fulfill as mayor.
Pittsburgh’s hidebound permitting system signals to builders that the city would rather they do anything else other than build in Pittsburgh. Those who’ve had to navigate the system for complex projects describe unclear guidelines, inconsistent forms and jargon across departments and mutually exclusive process requirements. Delays caused by one office will cause another office’s deadline to pass, sending the applicant back to square one.
Most frustrating of all, the city will often deny a permit without giving a clear reason, forcing the applicant to guess how to get it right next time. And each time costs several weeks or even months, during which costs rise and investors become anxious. In the case of affordable housing projects, these delays also cause vulnerable people to be without appropriate shelter for longer.
O’Connor and his team must figure out how to streamline this system while shifting the culture of city government away from gatekeeping and toward partnership with developers and builders. Both for the timely construction of Esplanade and to build a city where Esplanade can flourish, this is essential.
Connecting Esplanade
Lastly, Esplanade must be fully connected to the rest of Pittsburgh. In this, the Transit Revitalization Investment District (TRID) will be key.
Esplanade’s owner, the Piatt Companies, applied for and received TRID status, which means that real estate tax revenues above what the property currently generates (which in this case is very little) can be used to finance infrastructure improvements. At its best, a TRID is a way of capturing a development’s economic gains to extend and enhance its public value.
The first use of the TRID at Esplanade will be to convert the far-too-wide one-way-inbound Beaver Avenue to a two-way street, facilitating access to Esplanade from the rest of the North Side. This is essential work, but we don’t believe it will suffice to knit the development into the fabric of the city.
Esplanade will thrive best on its own terms, and will benefit Pittsburgh most, if it is connected to the city’s transit system. And there’s an obvious way to do just that, right at its edge: the terminus of the T light rail line. Extending the T roughly one-half mile, beneath the West End Bridge, would make Esplanade significantly more accessible and desirable both as a place to live and as a place to visit. It would also set the stage for further expansions up the Ohio River. Financing through the TRID is one of the few ways this modest expansion could be financially feasible.
Esplanade could be Pittsburgh’s defining real estate development for a generation. How it defines Pittsburgh, though, remains to be seen — and will depend on whether the city’s and region’s leaders are ready to make the most of it.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.