This editorial is part of an ongoing series entitled Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh, in which the Editorial Board collects and proposes new ways for Pittsburghers to think about their city during a time of transition. We invite you to share your own Big Ideas with us at opinion@post-gazette.com.
The Pittsburgh region is the most governmentally awkward in all of America. It begins with Allegheny County’s famously fragmented 130 municipalities — more than any other county or county-equivalent in America — but at least as challenging is the relatively small size of Pittsburgh itself within the larger Allegheny County.
While the city may dominate the county culturally and economically, it no longer has the population to do so politically. At its peak, Pittsburgh accounted for half of the county’s population; today, it accounts for less than one-quarter.
A city of 300,000 sits very uncomfortably in a county of 1.3 million, because it has big-city needs that require cooperation beyond its borders — but county officials have 1 million suburbanites to look after, as well, voters who often see their own interests as separate from and even opposed to the city’s.
At the same time, policies enacted by the city, as well as the conditions to which the city must react, affect the suburbs. From crime to zoning to taxation, Pittsburgh and its suburbs form a linked, dynamic system.
This is, of course, the argument for a city-county merger — but that’s beyond the scope of today’s Big Idea. It’s also an argument for merging responsibility for economic and housing policy.
The connection between city and county is clearest here, yet both are burdened with public agencies whose geographic silos make strategizing for the whole community all but impossible.
That’s why the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA) should merge with the county’s Redevelopment Authority (RAAC). And the city’s Housing Authority (HACP) and the McKeesport Housing Authority should merge with the county’s Housing Authority (ACHA).
Housing efficiency
First, housing. Balkanization of public housing agencies is a national problem — Pittsburgh has, surprisingly, one of the more centralized systems — that increases administrative costs while artificially limiting housing choice for people who qualify for assistance.
While it is possible for a family to apply for housing choice vouchers (HVY, also known as Section 8) in multiple jurisdictions, or to transfer an existing voucher from one authority to another, these are cumbersome processes many people aren’t aware of. A true countywide authority would increase both the number of qualifying households and the number of available units and vouchers, allowing for more efficient use of existing stock, and more options for people to find a place to live.
This is particularly important given the struggles of HACP to manage its HCV program, which has discouraged or chased away numerous landlords from participating. HACP is the biggest impediment to effective affordable housing policy in Pittsburgh. The shakeup occasioned by consolidation could only help its administration, while ensuring that housing affordability is treated, rightly, as a regional issue rather than strictly a city one.
Developing the region
Similar arguments hold for the redevelopment authorities. The URA has struggled in recent years due to underfunding — cuts in city transfers under the Gainey administration led to several layoffs this summer — and a shift in focus away from economic development and toward affordable housing. A consolidated agency could use limited resources more efficiently, while considering the overall economic and development needs of the city and its suburbs.
There is precedent for city-county cooperation in these areas. The Sports and Exhibition Authority (SEA) has been a joint agency of the city and county since its founding in 1954. In the late 1990s, the long-time director of the URA, Mulugetta Birru, actually ran Allegheny County Economic Development — simultaneously.
This roughly coincided with the development of the SouthSide Works and the Waterfront, two examples of major redevelopment projects — not uncontroversial then and now, but which have become integral to Pittsburgh’s built environment — whose effects have been truly regional.
A consolidated redevelopment agency would also be less exposed to politics — specifically the political needs of the Mayor of Pittsburgh, as well as entrenched anti-development forces.
Combined efforts
The potential drawbacks of housing-and-development mergers are notable. For instance, especially with regard to housing, having fewer agencies could make the region eligible for fewer state and federal grants. This is a perverse effect of the way the government grant system is designed, but it’s a real one. We would hope that merged authorities could enhance their grant-seeking operations, and that the gains in efficiency and regional strategy would make up for whatever opportunities are lost.
City of Pittsburgh residents and economic interests may reasonably fear that merged agencies would give the region’s urban core less attention. With the city accounting for less than a quarter of the county’s population, having city-specific public authorities may seem like the only way to get city-specific needs addressed.
This fear could be allayed through the organization of joint authorities’ governance, which should be designed to ensure significant influence of city elected leaders. Take the SEA, whose board consists of three members appointed by the mayor, three by the Allegheny County executive and one joint appointment. Given the city’s continued centrality to the economic health of the region, there’s every reason for new joint authorities to have similarly balanced board compositions. Further, some key roles could include city residency requirements.
With these mergers, Pittsburgh could become a model of metropolitan efficiency — something it’s never been known for. We encourage the next mayor and County Executive Sara Innamorato to empanel an expert commission, including public administration experts from the city’s universities, to study enhanced city-county cooperation in these areas.
The result could open more housing and economic opportunities to more people in Pittsburgh and beyond — while allowing the region’s leaders to focus more on delivering efficient services and equitable growth, rather than navigating unnecessary complexity.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.