These should be Pittsburgh’s post-steel glory years. Instead, the city’s and region’s civic life is marked by hesitancy, pessimism and nostalgia — and the resulting inability or unwillingness to take the bold steps that our region desperately needs.
Some of this is the result of uncertainty beyond Western Pennsylvania, with unpredictable tariffs, funding cuts and even military-police actions emanating from Washington, D.C. The political and economic climate in which Pittsburgh must operate has changed dramatically in the last eight months.
But much of Pittsburgh’s malaise is closer to home: a comparatively slow recovery from the COVID pandemic, a pronounced drop-off in construction paired with a pronounced increase in unsheltered homelessness, a growing wave of property-tax increases in response to market conditions and assessment practices. A new era of mediocrity-at-best among the city’s professional sports franchises hasn’t helped the mood.
The region could overcome these challenges if its leadership class were making its decisions and creating policies and plans for the future with a robust vision for Pittsburgh. But the closest we’ve gotten to that was U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick’s energy and tech summit, which was a step in the right direction, but necessarily incomplete, and also partisan.
Yet there are two events on the horizon that could, and should, be catalysts for a renewed vision for a revitalized Pittsburgh: the inauguration of a new mayor in January and the NFL Draft in April. These will provide opportunities for thinking about the city and the region’s challenges and for experimenting with new ways of doing things, in Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania as a whole. They offer opportunities for a lively and public discussion of big ideas for changing Pittsburgh and the region’s future.
In anticipation of these events, and in recognition of the need for Pittsburgh to overcome the friction of indecision and risk-aversion, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board is beginning a new occasional editorial feature, which we’re calling Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh.
Losing ground
One of the most noticeable trends in Pittsburgh in recent years has been a steady retreat from ambition. Nascent plans for maglevs and gondolas from years past are remembered scornfully today as vain and unrealistic — which they may have been! — but they also represented a willingness to swing for the fences, to think about how Pittsburgh could make a splash in the Allegheny rather than hit a few singles here and there.
At the same time, the biggest projects regional leaders have taken on have been increasingly abstract, such as eliminating inequities based on class, race and gender. These are very real problems worthy of significant attention, but they are also largely beyond the scope of a city or county to solve.
Further, we believe that Pittsburgh can make greater progress in mitigating inequities, especially in resource-intensive areas like affordable housing, if the region is more economically dynamic. That won’t just mean more tax dollars to deploy, but also more opportunities for everyday people to find jobs with family-sustaining wages and to start businesses of their own, and more chances for people to begin community projects.
We are not so naïve as to think that a rising tide lifts all boats equally, but it can allow those resting on the shoals to float again, while bringing others closer to safe harbors. It is still better for the tide to rise than to fall.
This all takes place in the context of a region that suffers from the worst natural population decline — that is, deaths versus births — anywhere in America. To stand still is to lose ground, and quickly. We believe Pittsburgh needs a jolt of momentum at least as much right now as at any time in its recent history.
Squandered potential
Southwestern Pennsylvania enjoys extraordinary riches, from natural resources to educational institutions, from beautifully rugged geography to striking architecture to dozens upon dozens of towns and neighborhoods that offer the history, authenticity and proximity that is increasingly valued, especially by younger Americans. And, importantly, an unusual degree of local patriotism and a commitment to make our region better.
This should be Pittsburgh’s time to shine. Yet generating enthusiasm about Pittsburgh’s present and future, and a plan for deploying the region’s assets in a strategic way, has proved challenging.
We believe this is due in part to confoundingly complex institutional structures (both governmental and nongovernmental), in part to a relative lack of savvy and inspiring leaders who can organize competing interests and in part to a habit, related to the first two, of thinking small rather than thinking big.
Thinking big
Big Ideas for a Better Pittsburgh will present proposals for improving life in southwestern Pennsylvania that go beyond the usual policy tweaks and small-time building projects. They will generally be speculative, which means we don’t plan to endorse ongoing projects but rather to introduce something new to the conversation, and plausible, which means there’s potentially a real path toward funding and completion.
Sometimes they will reflect ideas that are in circulation, but are considered to be politically risky, and therefore never progress beyond conversation. But that’s exactly why needed changes never happen.
Some of the areas we’ll be considering are major infrastructure projects, moonshot investments to tackle long-term problems such as public education and affordable housing, and the legacy problem of governmental fragmentation. The editorial features will be occasional, but should appear at least twice a month through the NFL Draft, and possibly beyond.
We’d also like some of the Big Ideas to come from our readers. If you have an ambitious concept for improving Pittsburgh, send us an email at opinion@post-gazette.com, and make sure to put “Big Idea” in the subject line.
Pittsburgh’s potential is as great as it has ever been — maybe greater — but there’s little to no vision for transforming that potential to reality. Let’s start crafting one.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.