New data on the City of Pittsburgh’s spending on staff overtime from Controller Rachael Heisler confirms her own analysis, and the Post-Gazette Editorial Board’s, from earlier this year: Mayor Ed Gainey’s 2025 budget seriously underestimated this year’s spending, giving a false impression of the city’s fiscal health.
Indeed, the overtime overages provide more evidence that this year’s city budget was essentially a political document designed to mask the city’s money problems during Mr. Gainey’s re-election bid. Yet eight of nine members of City Council — Theresa Kail-Smith being the dissenter — approved the budget, so the blame certainly isn’t confined to the Mayor’s Office.
The unavoidable fact is this: After squandering the historic federal pandemic relief windfall and surpluses generated during the Peduto administration, Pittsburgh is spending a lot more money than it’s taking in. Therefore, due both to structural challenges and budget decisions made during the Gainey administration, it is very likely the city will have to seek additional revenues.
That is: A tax hike is coming. The only questions are what form it will take, and which mayor will own it. We believe it’s only fair for Mr. Gainey or, failing that, City Council to propose a realistic tax increase before the end of this year, for the 2026 fiscal year.
Predictable crisis
Last fall, the Editorial Board raised the alarm: In the Department of Public Safety alone, Mr. Gainey’s proposed 2025 budget projected spending $10 million less than in 2024, even as EMS and police staffing crises only worsened. We wrote: “The overtime figure is, for all intents and purposes, fraudulent.” And with a projected operating result of only $3 million, that made the entire budget fraudulent.
After the first quarter of 2025, Ms. Heisler reported that spending figures were proving just that: With 25% of the year gone, the city had already spent 39% of its overtime budget across several departments, including 66% of the EMS overtime allowance. If those trends were to continue, the overruns would be $15 million just in Public Safety.
Gainey administration officials claimed that this was much ado about nothing: The first quarter, with snowy days and St. Patrick’s Day festivities, always requires extra overtime. Everything, they say, would sort itself out.
But now the second quarter is in the books, and Ms. Heisler has released overtime figures that, unsurprisingly, expose the administration’s bluster: Pittsburgh has now spent 77% of its allowance. That’s another 38% on top of the first quarter’s 39%, which means the pace of spending didn’t slow down at all.
The details are astounding: Through half the year, the city has used 70% of its police overtime budget, 70% of fire, 119% of EMS and 278% of facilities operations within Public Works, in part due to stormy weather. All told, the city is on track to spend over $20 million above budget for overtime this year.
Fiscal profligacy
This is all on top of spending that has ballooned on Mr. Gainey’s watch. The difference between the years 2022 and 2024 is particularly illuminating.
In 2022, the last year governed by a Peduto administration budget, revenues came in high and expenditures low: In what appeared to be a strong emergence from the pandemic, Pittsburgh brought in a remarkable $115 million more than it spent: $703 million in, and $588 million out.
By 2024, revenues had declined by a few million dollars, largely due to write-downs on commercial real estate caused by changes in the office market and Allegheny County’s troubled assessment system. But expenditures increased by 16%, or nearly $100 million. Two years after achieving a 9-figure surplus, the city only brought in $18 million more than it spent.
But that is a very misleading figure. First, that result was juiced by that final year of $47 million in federal pandemic relief funds. In other words, all on its own the city was already running a $29 million deficit last year.
Second, these “surplus” and “deficit” figures only take into account the everyday expenses of running the city. They do not take into account spending on capital projects, or legally required transfers to trust funds, such as $10 million a year each to the Housing Opportunity Fund and the Stop the Violence Fund. In practice, Pittsburgh needs to run a surplus of about $40 million to fulfill its obligations without dipping into its reserves.
But Mr. Gainey proposed, and City Council passed, a 2025 budget that foresees only a $3 million surplus — which has already been devoured by the overtime overages.
The right thing
Pittsburgh retains a reasonably healthy reserve fund, refilled under Act 47 state oversight and boosted in recent years. But, at current trends, just one more year like this one will deplete it below the legal minimum of 10% of annual expenditures.
The choices are the same as ever: reduce spending, increase revenues or both. The first is more difficult than meets the eye. For instance, the 100-plus new city workers hired by Mr. Gainey have union protections. And any savings that can be generated will likely need to be plowed into the capital budget to address decades of deferred maintenance in everything from public safety vehicles to water fountains.
Further, property tax headwinds have slowed, but not ended completely. The city will continue to see drops, and owe refunds, in commercial real estate taxes.
The city of Pittsburgh will almost certainly need to raise taxes — just as Allegheny County did this year. That's the financial reality the city faces. This would have been avoided with sound fiscal management over the past few years, but the city did not enjoy that.
Council must insist on a realistic budget from the mayor — unlike this year’s farce — including cuts to spending and enhanced revenues. That will be a hard budget to pass, but anything else would reward Mr. Gainey’s mismanagement.
Worse, not to do so would only delay facing a problem that will not go away and will only get worse. The future of the city demands action now.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.