A durable financial arrangement between the City of Pittsburgh and its major nonprofits is one of the most important missing pieces in the region’s civic ecosystem. Such a deal would heal a long-term rift between the city and several of its most important institutions; would help to stabilize the city’s structural financial deficit; and would set a new tone for public-private civic cooperation in a city where a spirit of collaboration, now weakened, was once one of its most celebrated and important attributes.

A unique opportunity to strike a historic deal is on the horizon, with the all-but-certain inauguration of Democratic mayoral nominee Corey O’Connor at the beginning of next year. It is in the interests of all stakeholders to seize this coming moment, in order to demonstrate that it is not just possible but desirable and effective for achieving public goods for government and civic institutions to find common ground.

We believe that the prerequisites of a deal are sliding into place. In addition to new elected leadership, the city’s crisis of funding for replacement and maintenance of public safety and public works vehicles provides a perfect opportunity for nonprofit contributions to help the city in a way that is both targeted and directly related to the city services these institutions rely on.

Indeed, we are more hopeful than we have been in many years that Pittsburgh’s largest nonprofits can once again be full partners, as opposed to arm’s-length associates or even adversaries, with the city they call home.

Advertise with us

How we got here

The recent history of attempts to squeeze non-tax contributions from the city’s nonprofit sector begins with former Mayor Tom Murphy, who struck a payments-in-lieu-of-taxes deal with a group of 100 organizations that brought in about $5 million per year. This continued into the 2010s, when former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl had a falling-out with UPMC, which culminated in bringing suit against the healthcare giant in state court.

That proved to be a dead end. Former Mayor Bill Peduto ended the suit, and spent nearly his entire eight years in office seeking a more permanent solution. He eventually contrived the ONEPGH program, which was an independent organization to which the nonprofits would contribute and from which the city would draw for civic initiatives.

Mr. Peduto touted $115 million in commitments over five years from the Big Five — UPMC, Highmark Health, the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University and Duquesne University — though some of this was money the institutions were spending on their own capital projects, such as infrastructure, that had a public element.

Current Mayor Ed Gainey described ONEPGH as insufficient and unacceptably separate from the city’s general fund and scuttled it in his first months in office. (This was obviously motivated at least partially by SEIU Healthcare’s feud with UPMC.) Mr. Gainey tried a new approach: challenging the tax exempt status of individual properties owned by nonprofits.

This quickly became a shambles, as the administration challenged museums, homes owned by disabled veterans and the entirety of Children’s Hospital. The tax revenues generated from the plan have barely matched the costs in outside counsel, let alone the costs in staff time and attention. So the city remains at square one.

Advertise with us

Only fair

All by themselves, the Big Five own real estate valued at $4.5 billion in the city alone. That cashes out to about $36 million a year in missed tax revenue.

The nonprofits are quick to point out they contribute to the city in other ways: tens of millions in other taxes, not to mention their overall contributions to the region’s economy in terms of talent attraction, research, business spin-offs, free healthcare and other benefits. This is all very fair.

Yet these institutions also cannot thrive without city government and city services. Further, Pittsburgh has an unusually large amount of non-taxable real estate, which means that while these nonprofits do make the city more dynamic, they are also contributing to its budget woes.

Non-tax contributions or PILOTs are commonplace in other cities, from Boston to Erie. These deals are expressions of mutual dependency and mutual good faith. Pittsburgh needs one. But how to strike one after so many years of eroded trust on both sides?

A deal for everyone

Both sides will have to give a little. Specifically, the nonprofits will have to concede that their funds can be used for basic services, while the city will have to concede that it can’t use that money for whatever it wants. Here’s a proposal: a trust fund for the purchase and maintenance of city-owned vehicles.

Advertise with us

Broken-down ambulances and snow plows have become some of the most potent symbols of Pittsburgh’s financial duress. In order to keep this year’s and future years’ budgets artificially balanced, the Gainey administration has cut vehicle expenditures to the bone: $6 million this year, and $3 million or less thereafter. Meanwhile, the best estimate for the actual cost of replacing aging vehicles is over $20 million per year.

We propose a vehicle trust fund with a city match on nonprofit contributions. The match ensures the city doesn’t continue to underfund vehicles by moving its existing commitments elsewhere, thereby defeating the purpose for the nonprofits. If the nonprofits pitched in $20 million and the city a 50% match, that $30 million would cover consistent, timely vehicle replacement plus the lion’s share of the city’s multimillion-dollar maintenance contract.

For the nonprofits, this would represent an investment in city services they directly benefit from. For the city, it would relieve one of the most difficult and expensive line items for fulfilling its public health and safety responsibilities.

Mr. Gainey’s particular antipathy for UPMC made striking a deal acceptable to all parties impossible. With a new mayor, however, comes an opportunity for a new, more collaborative approach. It would be in the nonprofits’ interest to reward such an entreaty, and in the mayor’s interest to get a deal that will have tangible positive effects for everyday Pittsburghers.

And it would be in Pittsburgh’s interest, and the entire region’s, to inaugurate a new era of collaborative civic leadership.