What do Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Louisville, Nashville, Columbus, Asheville and Huntsville, along with thousands of smaller communities in between, all have in common? They depend on the waters of the Ohio River watershed.
Yet despite covering over 200,000 square miles and containing over 30 million residents, the Ohio River basin is one of the few water resource areas in America that lacks an official plan for federal environmental and infrastructure investment. This means these crucial waterways — there are over 200,000 miles of tributaries that flow into the roughly 1,000 mile-long Ohio — are missing out on tens, and maybe hundreds of millions of dollars in projects which have a proven tracks record of providing more than three times their value in economic benefits.
It’s time to change that. Earlier this month, the Ohio River Basin Alliance along with the National Wildlife Federation and the University of Louisville’s Christina Lee Brown Envirome Institute released a draft report on investment in the watershed, which is slated to be submitted to Congress later this year. This document catalogs the needs of the basin and the opportunities for environmental restoration and other improvements, largely expanding on existing programs that are far too small in scope for the scale of the region.
There is a public engagement session regarding the report on Wednesday, June 25, at the Spartan Community Center of Hazelwood, and the overall public comment period will close on July 18. When the report ultimately makes it to Congress, we urge swift action to secure high-impact investments in this critical, high-need region.
Lack of attention
Few people think of themselves as residents of the Ohio River basin. That’s in part because the watershed is so remarkably varied, including everything from Indiana flatlands to the Tennessee Smokies. Pittsburghers rarely think of themselves as sharing much with people in Louisville or Paducah, even though we’re at the headwaters of the river that gives those places a reason to exist.
This lack of identification with what the French called La Belle Rivière isn’t just a curiosity; it’s a political problem, making it easy for the region not to receive federal attention. Happily, there is a bipartisan Congressional Ohio River Basin Caucus, but fewer than half of the watershed’s members of Congress have joined. In Pennsylvania, only Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall, is a member.
The Ohio River Basin includes some of the most environmentally sensitive, and degraded, regions of the country. Over half of the 200,000 miles of streams and rivers in the watershed are considered “impaired,” which means the water flowing in these channels, and through Ohio Valley communities, doesn’t meet defined water quality standards.
It also covers some of the most economically forlorn parts of America: Nearly half of the watershed’s 30 million residents live in counties that are considered economically “distressed” (bottom 10% of U.S. counties) or “at risk” (10th to 25th percentiles).
Areas that are not as distressed are receiving much more support. While the Ohio River watershed has no plan for federal investments, other water resource areas are getting tens or hundreds of millions of dollars a year. The San Francisco Bay Area gets $54 million. The waters the drain into Long Island Sound get $40 million. The Great Lakes get over $350 million.
Case study
What’s the case for spending federal taxpayer money improving America’s waterways, especially when the executive branch — and, to some degree, the public mood — is hostile to expanding government commitments? Consider the success of the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative.
The GLRI is the biggest ongoing coordinated federal investment in domestic water resources, involving hundreds of projects in eight Great Lakes states over about 15 years. Its projects, amounting to over $4 billion since 2010, include everything from funding for litter traps in an Erie, Pa., creek to mitigate trash in Presque Isle Bay to major remediation of industrial pollution in Milwaukee, Wis.
In 2018, a University of Michigan study calculated the economic effects of the first half-decade of GLRI initiatives. The finding: “The GLRI was designed to be an environmental restoration program, not an economic development program, but it nonetheless has produced substantial economic benefits for the Great Lakes region.” Specifically, the researchers found $3.35 in new economic activity for each $1 invested in the Great Lakes environment, attributable to increases in tourism, recreation and new construction along previous unattractive waterfronts.
The report singled out Erie, Pa., including a quarter-billion dollars in waterfront development since the GLRI kicked off, alongside substantial increases in tourism. The refreshed reputation of the lakefront, the report argues, is in part responsible for an increase in young adults moving to or staying in the region.
In short: If you clean it, people and money will come.
A worthy plan
The needs of the Ohio River basin are vast. From the residual effects of careless industrial activity to ongoing toxic mine drainage to combined sewer-stormwater runoff, the region’s waterways struggle with poor quality and poor reputation.
This keeps people from enjoying the Ohio River watershed’s tremendous natural assets; reduces quality of life and attractiveness to newcomers; and neuters private investment in everything from rural recreational boating businesses to big-city high-rises.
As it stands, a variety of state and federal environmental programs address these issues, but in a small-scale and uncoordinated way. There are no investments in a comprehensive Ohio Valley plan — as there are for the Great Lakes and a dozen other water resource areas — because there’s no federal structure for such a plan to exist. This is leaving billions in new private investments on the table.
The work of the Ohio River Basin Alliance and its partners, including members of Congress from both parties, to change this is absolutely essential. We urge members of the public to participate in engagement about the watershed investment report, and more local members of Congress to champion the cause.
For the environment, for public health and for population and economic growth, these are among the most important investments the federal government can make.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.