A foreclosure action against the developer of one of the signature residential projects meant to renew Downtown Pittsburgh, reported by the Pittsburgh Business Times, casts doubt on whether the announced $600 million investment will ever be realized.
When Gov. Josh Shapiro joined local leaders last October to announce the full details of a Downtown revitalization plan, the Post-Gazette Editorial board joined with many southwestern Pennsylvanians in expressing relief. The roadmap, which envisioned $600 million in investment in the Golden Triangle resulting in major infrastructure upgrades and about 1,000 units of new housing, finally put meat on the bones of what had been a skeletal vision for renewing the central business district.
But we also urged Pittsburghers to look at the fine print. Of the $600 million, only about $120 million involved hard-money commitments to directly support development. Then another $85 million regarded a trio of neighborhood improvements: a refurbished Market Square; an activated Point State Park (postponed until after the 2026 NFL Draft); and the Arts Landing project along Eighth Avenue in the Cultural District.
That $200 million is nothing to sneeze at, but it’s not $600 million. The remaining two-thirds of the plan involved private investment that was expected to be facilitated by the public investment, largely in seven significant residential high-rise developments in the Golden Triangle.
One of the most substantial of those projects, and the only one to be primarily new construction as opposed to conversion or renovation, was the City Club Apartments to be built above the YWCA Building on Wood Street. The Detroit-based developer had planned about 300 units for the 24-story project, accounting for nearly 30% of the units in the Downtown plan. The price tag of $120 million was also about 30% of the projected private development.
Now, however, the Business Times has reported that one of the property owner’s lenders has filed a foreclosure action against it. The project is unlikely to proceed under current ownership, and a transfer of ownership would likely start the clock again on a project that’s already been several years in the making.
This comes after a total of about $10 million of state Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program and local Urban Redevelopment Authority money was committed to the project, raising the question of how well the seven projects were vetted.
City Club Apartments had closed on the YWCA property in April 2022, after having won zoning board approvals for its plans, which would have included a few dozen rent-controlled units. But even then the project was behind.
In the three years since, costs have risen sharply. Even the funding provided by the Downtown plan does not seem to have been enough, and come soon enough, to keep the project on track. The Business Times adds that City Club has encountered similar struggles with projects in other cities.
And so it appears that the expected $600 million Downtown investment should be reduced to less than $500 million, and the total housing count dropped from 1,000 units to about 700. Mayor Ed Gainey has continued to tout the $600 million figure — for a plan he had only a small role in bringing to pass — even after the foreclosure was reported.
The Downtown plan got on the right track by helping developers close funding gaps caused by high costs and stingy banks. But economic conditions and individual projects are dynamic: Nothing can be taken for granted, and no one should take a victory lap until the projects are all completed.
The apparent failure of one of the signature Downtown developments should make Pittsburghers wonder just how much of the touted $600 million will ever make it to the Golden Triangle.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.