Third in a series on Pittsburgh’s struggles to maintain and upgrade its parks and recreation facilities.

Among the most frustrating delayed projects in Pittsburgh’s parks-and-recreation backlog aren’t green spaces, but buildings. Most of Pittsburgh’s 11 recreation centers and 13 Health Active Living Centers (HALC) — that is, senior centers — are housed in old structures, and several are in shabby condition. And some, like the Cowley Recreation Center in Troy Hill, have been boarded up for years, awaiting renewed investment.

The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has previously reported on nearly $18 million in proposed upgrades to recreation centers, using federal pandemic relief funds, the vast majority of which did not come to pass. Most of the money originally set aside for those projects was ultimately moved elsewhere, because the city simply couldn’t spend it before it expires at the end of 2026.

But why? Last week, we looked at how “community engagement” hamstrings parks upgrade projects, with several months often spent seeking neighborhood feedback, which delays submissions for numerous permits, which increases costs, which ultimately hurts the very taxpayers being consulted. This week, we will examine the particular case of the Brighton Heights HALC, and how a one-word change in city law, followed by a lengthy implementation process, deprived neighborhood residents of an expanded senior center.

Advertise with us

Funds, but no action

The Brighton Heights HALC is located in a stately century-old building on McClure Avenue, said to have been built to house elderly women and possibly nuns. But despite the structure’s extensive footprint, the senior center is relegated to the basement, because the top two floors have been allowed to fall into serious disrepair.

Plans to renovate the building go back a decade, and funding goes back to 2021, when the Peduto administration put in its budget over $1 million in bond-financed funding alongside over $2 million in state Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program (RACP) money. Every year since, until 2025, the Gainey administration has also budgeted bond funding for the facility: $1.2 million in 2022, $950,000 in 2023 and $800,000 in 2024.

Over time, as delays mounted due to the city’s inability to work through its backlog of projects, the scale of the renovation shrunk to just the first floor, disappointing community members who had hoped for a second-floor community center. But finally, in mid-2024, the scaled-back project went out to bid.

Yet nearly a year later, nothing has happened. The reason, it seems, is the struggle to implement a one-word change to city law made early last year.

A reasonable fix

Ordinance 1 of 2024 was passed by City Council 9-0 with minimal discussion — and for good reason. The legislation fixed an obvious problem with the city’s Equal Opportunity Review Commission: While the commission was clearly meant to have the authority to enforce the city’s diverse contracting requirements — that is, ensuring sufficient participation by businesses owned by women, racial minorities, LGBTQ people and veterans — a stray word in existing law severely limited its ability to actually ensure compliance.

Advertise with us

Presumably due to an oversight when the city’s contracting regulations were previously expanded, the law read, “The City shall have the power to impose sanctions upon contractors and subcontractors found to be in non-compliance with the residency requirements set forth in this Chapter.” This limited the EORC’s ability to punish contractors to violations of residency rules, as opposed to the broader remit clearly envisioned in the rest of the law.

Last year’s Ordinance 1 simply struck the word “residency.”

But implementing that change was not so simple: It required new language in requests for proposals — a new section of nearly 1,000 words of instructions and regulations is now part of the RFP — and new forms for contractors to fill out, such as more extensive documentation of outreach to diverse subcontractors.

We can place aside the question of the prudence of these regulations and observe something everyone can agree on: This process took far too long. For instance, when the Brighton Heights HALC went out to bid on June 17 of last year — five months after the ordinance was passed — it was still based on the old documents. That didn’t need to be a problem, but the city made it one.

Delayed implementation

Contractors bid on the Brighton Heights project like usual, and by the late-July deadline it looked like the project should be on track for completion in late 2024 or early 2025. But then, after bids were submitted, the city canceled the RFP entirely: “Insufficient spec,” reads the explanation on the city’s procurement website.

Advertise with us

In November, with no visible progress at the site, Joseph Glassbrenner, president of the Brighton Heights Citizens Federation, explained in the organization’s newsletter: “I’ve been informed [by the city] the architectural drawings were lacking key components … that delayed the bidding process.” Mr. Glassbrenner had been misinformed: The primary problem — and possibly the only problem — delaying the senior center renovations was the long-delayed implementation of Ordinance 1.

Remarkably, the new RFP for the Brighton Heights HALC didn’t go out until April 8, 2025 — nearly 15 months after the one-word amendment was passed. It was also the first Public Works bid to include the new language. In other words, it appears to have been held up for nearly a year to use as the trial run for the new process.

That’s one more year of a basement senior center in a beautiful building; one more year of deterioration; one more year of inflation and other cost increases.

There was no good reason to cancel the Brighton Heights senior center RFP after contractors had already bid on it. The old regulatory language may have been incomplete, but it wasn’t obsolete or illegal. Making the seniors of Brighton Heights wait a full year while the city got its act together was unnecessary.

Altogether, this episode demonstrates once again a system where good intentions meet poor execution, and where there’s a bureaucratic bias in favor of delay rather than action. And it’s everyday people who pay the price.