As the United States of America approaches the 250th anniversary of its founding, the country has achieved something many observers thought was generations if not centuries away: It has produced a Pope of the Roman Catholic Church.

Robert Francis Prevost, originally of Dolton, Ill., a near suburb of Chicago, is now Pope Leo XIV. He is also a Peruvian citizen, having spent over two decades serving as a missionary and later bishop in the northern city of Chiclayo. In his background, his experiences and his languages — he can speak five fluently and can read in two more — he is a man who bridges cultures and worldviews.

This makes Leo a particularly suitable global leader for a time of polarization, of distrust and of misunderstanding. In his first remarks from the loggia in St. Peter’s Basilica, he alluded to this, saying to the crowd, “You help us to build bridges with dialogue and encounter so we can all be one people always in peace.”

Leo will be most effective in promoting this dialogue and understanding if he consistently challenges people in all of today’s ideological camps. That means encouraging factions of all kinds to inspect their own assumptions and to consider others’ perspectives, and to respect the good faith of those with whom they disagree.

Advertise with us

The role of any religious leader who speaks from a long-developed tradition can never be captured or understood in the political categories of the present moment. Attempts to label Leo as “woke” or “conservative,” “progressive” or “anti-Trump,” or even as “moderate” will fail to capture the breadth of his mission and ministry, and his responsibility to a teaching he inherited and is tasked with passing on.

If Leo’s reign is remembered well in the church and around the world, it will be if he successfully transcends those categories.

Response to revolution

Cardinal Prevost’s selection of the name “Leo” calls to mind the most recent Pope Leo, the thirteenth of that name, who reigned from 1878 to 1903, at the time the second-longest tenure since St. Peter himself. The previous Leo is a fitting model for a pope in a changing and challenging world.

Leo XIII reigned during the peak of the Industrial Revolution and the painful birth of a new economy: crowded cities, dangerous factories, emptying countrysides, destitute workers. In response, in 1891 he authored one of the most influential documents not only in church history but in recent history full stop: “Rerum novarum,” sometimes called “Rights and Duties of Capital and Labor.” In this letter, Leo laid the foundations of what is today called Catholic Social Teaching (CST), or the application of theological and moral principles to the contemporary economy.

“Rerum novarum,” and CST as it has developed in the following 130 years, challenges both capitalists and socialists, both employers and workers, both those celebrating change and those desiring to restrict change. Above all, it places the notion of the common good at the center — that is, “the sum total of social conditions which allow people, either as groups or as individuals, to reach their fulfillment more fully and more easily,” as the Second Vatican Council put it.

Advertise with us

Achieving that common good requires everybody to sacrifice their self-interest in some way. It’s the only way to live truly together.

In these times

In honoring Leo XIII, Cardinal Prevost has signaled a Leonine response to another moment of great change: artificial intelligence, climate crisis, record migration. Moving toward a better world, one where the dignity of people and of truth is respected, will require the witness of a Pope who says hard things to every faction while articulating a compelling vision of human dignity and human flourishing.

We can’t know what the future holds, but there are early signs that this new Leo is the right man for these hard times. He has experience around the world but is grounded in two very different places: the United States, a world superpower and the engine of modernity, and Peru, where he worked in large cities and the desperately poor interior of the country. He can speak to the peoples’ experience as it is manifested so differently throughout the world, in a way few other world leaders can.

Further, he has consistently criticized political leaders whose actions depart from respecting human dignity as he and the church see it, from Peruvian leftists to American populists.

Already, political factions in America, in the church and elsewhere have tried to claim Leo XIV as their own or declare him an implacable member of an opposing group. We think, from what we know of him, they will be proven wrong.

Leo XIV, the first American pope, is uniquely positioned to point to a better way forward for all people. It will take the courage to speak boldly, and above all the courage to be hated. In other words, it will require what the church and the world expect the Holy Father to be: a reflection of the life of Jesus Christ himself.