Second in a series on Pittsburgh’s struggles to maintain and upgrade its parks.
The process the City of Pittsburgh’s Department of Public Works must follow to complete parks and recreation projects hamstrings competent city workers and leaves citizens waiting years for projects to be completed, while taxpayer dollars are wasted as costs rise during the process. Procedures that were introduced for good reason, from meeting with community groups to seeking numerous permits (including from within the city itself), have congealed into a years-long slog.
It is essential to reform this system to allow city government to fulfill its own promises.
Byzantine process
Among the dozens of delayed parks and recreation projects being tracked by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, one of the most common sticking points is community engagement. Projects will often languish for several months or longer as city officials painstakingly seek feedback, which delays the creation of final plans to submit for permitting.
The costs of these delays in time and money — and, ultimately, the ability of the community to enjoy the finished product — is rarely worth the cost. The city should limit community engagement meetings while emphasizing online options, which give residents a voice while minimizing delays and acrimony.
Here’s a sketch of the process by which a parks and recreation project goes from idea to reality in Pittsburgh.
In June, the Department of Public Works submits project ideas for consideration for the next year’s capital budget. Executive branch leaders consider these requests in consultation with members of City Council. After some horse trading, a certain number make the cut, and Council approves them in December as part of the next year’s budget.
In a perfect world, DPW can begin early design and community engagement immediately in January. This rarely happens, unless a project gets pushed to the head of the queue by elected officials, because so many projects are backed up. Only after community engagement is complete can DPW finalize an approved conceptual design, which forms the basis of technical drawings, which are submitted for permits.
These permits are not the focus of this editorial, but they can include working with everything from the city’s own Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections to the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, the Allegheny County Conservation District and the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority. This phase of overlapping wait periods and deadlines can take anywhere from several months to several years.
But that byzantine process can’t even get started until community engagement is complete.
Bias toward building
For some people, community engagement has an almost religious significance. Nothing can be done without it, because it will, it is thought, ensure the success of any project or policy. It is sometimes described as essential to, or even synonymous with, democracy itself.
But there’s a reason why direct democracy failed in ancient Athens and fails today: It was impossible to get anything done.
It is important to know what people want. It is not necessary to hold multiple public meetings over the course of several months, nor to seek consensus on details where unanimity is unlikely or impossible.
These meetings give platforms to, and can be easily hijacked by, the most disagreeable voices in the room. They will sometimes worsen, rather than alleviate, existing tensions in the community. And they can encourage doing nothing, because doing nothing avoids making a choice that will upset some faction or another.
The truth is that, in most cases, what will assuage community concerns most effectively is not interminable community engagement: It’s actually building something.
Once a playground is built or a splash pad is installed or a ballfield is renovated, most people will forget about their misgivings about this or that detail, and will simply be happy that children and their families are enjoying a neighborhood park once again.
Truly engaging
Right now, the Department of Public Works essentially wings it when it comes to community engagement. The procedure depends on the project, and the needs of the neighborhood.
That makes sense, but we’d like to see the department lean more heavily on the EngagePgh website. This service, introduced by the Peduto administration, allows residents to track projects and, in a limited way, to interact with the people managing them. For instance, they can submit questions, respond to polls or answer questions about their hopes for a local park that’s up for renovation.
The Gainey administration has used EngagePgh inconsistently. For instance, several active projects list as their responsible person employees who no longer work for the city.
In many if not most cases, a functional and monitored EngagePgh page is all the community engagement a project needs. We’d like to see it written into policy that EngagePgh is the primary form of engagement for parks and recreation projects, for a limited period of time, and that full meetings are only held in unusual circumstances, such as complex projects or communities where requiring internet access might be a barrier to participation.
It would also be a prudent use of the Parks Tax to hire an employee to manage parks and recreation engagement, especially to ensure that residents who use EngagePgh feel heard. This would help more parks projects get completed more quickly: One of the reasons the city has struggled to use Parks Tax funds is the community engagement bottleneck.
These modest reforms aren’t about silencing community voices: They’re about returning community engagement to its original purpose — understanding the desires of those who use the parks — and avoiding as far as possible the heckler’s veto. In the end, actually fixing Pittsburgh’s parks is what communities want, and need.
The first part of this series can be read here.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.