A proposal by Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, to regionalize public transit in southwestern Pennsylvania should be given serious consideration in Harrisburg. While the idea would come with risks, if thoughtfully executed such a regional transit authority could be more efficient and less costly, while maintaining or even expanding operations in Allegheny County and its surrounding counties.

With transit agencies across the commonwealth facing a common crisis of funding and threatening deep service cuts, now is not the time for timidity, or for another in a long line of short-term bandage solutions. Local and state leaders need to think big, reimagining our legacy transit institutions, and the state’s relationship with them, for the 21st century. Crucially, regionalization is not a bailout of Allegheny County’s Pittsburgh Regional Transit: It is a way to help ensure transit in big and small communities in the region can survive into the future.

County lines, which determine the borders for both existing transit authorities, are essentially arbitrary when overlaid on current development patterns. That is to say, there is no good reason — beyond the legacy of county-based systems — that a commuter bus to Pittsburgh from Beaver Falls or Greensburg or Butler should be managed by a different agency than one from Coraopolis or McKeesport or McCandless.

The proof of this is in the already-existing exceptions: PRT buses already nudge into Beaver County at Ambridge and Westmoreland County at New Kensington and Trafford. Because it would be ridiculous not to.

Advertise with us

There are other exceptions, as well: Most of the commuter bus routes from outlying counties make at least a few stops in Allegheny County outside the Golden Triangle, such as Beaver County Transit Authority’s pick-ups along Ohio River Boulevard. And the Mid-Mon Valley Transit Authority is shared between Washington and Westmoreland counties, as the communities it serves straddle the river that serves as the county line.

The Pittsburgh region as a whole straddles several counties, and it would only make sense for that region to share an integrated transit system. This would allow for route-making that fully disregards county lines, more accurately responding to demand while removing redundancies. Further, it should be more efficient to administer such a system through a single organization with consistent technology (such as ConnectCards) and fare structure, rather than in several overlapping organizations.

Mr. Costa’s proposal does not immediately merge the region’s transit authorities, but would “provide incentives” for the creation of a Southwestern Pennsylvania Transit Authority. What those incentives would be has not yet been announced, and will determine if Mr. Costa’s bill is the correct way to reach this end.

Among the most important concerns are those regarding fairness to outlying counties. It will be essential, for instance, that local funding requirements for a regional authority be defined equitably. Lawrence County’s contribution, for instance, should be proportionate to the services it receives; it mustn’t subsidize Allegheny County.

Also, local service in outlying counties must not get lost in the shuffle. The most popular transit offerings in these counties are not Pittsburgh commuter buses, but town-to-town routes and neighborhood circulators that give people access to job centers — such as the Nemacolin resort in Fayette County — as well as amenities in their local small cities. Any regionalization plan must maintain services in these outlying communities.

Advertise with us

With those conditions met, however, a truly regional system could and should provide more efficient connectivity across southwestern Pennsylvania for all residents — and with less overhead, to boot. It wouldn’t solve the funding crisis, but could make it easier to manage, while reorganizing regional transit in response to today’s circumstances.

Mr. Costa is starting an essential conversation, and we hope Harrisburg leaders in both parties will participate in good faith.