A proposal to share a superintendent between two small (and shrinking) Beaver County school districts highlights the challenges facing small districts, and the necessity of creative solutions to reduce spending while ensuring long-term survival.

New Brighton Area and Rochester Area districts are good candidates for shared services and, ultimately, a full merger. They include socioeconomically similar areas, and have similar tax rates, reducing the political friction that typically comes with municipal and school district consolidation.

Sharing a superintendent, which is expected to reduce costs at each district by about $70,000 a year, will allow for deeper coordination and collaboration. Rochester is down to about 700 students from 1,200 at the turn of the millennium, while New Brighton is down to 1,200 from 2,100. The year 2000 figures themselves represent radical declines from the Beaver Valley’s heyday.

Deeper collaboration through shared leadership — and eventually consolidation — will allow them to save money, share their strengths and provide some of the educational and extracurricular options typically reserved for larger districts.

Advertise with us

New Brighton Area and Rochester Area are hardly the only small districts in the region. Midland Borough in Beaver County has only about 200 students and doesn’t offer high school. Western Beaver, a rural district, also has about 700 students across K-12.

Meanwhile, Allegheny County is known around the country for its municipal fragmentation (130 municipalities), but it is also remarkably balkanized educationally (43 school districts). Many of those districts are very small. Besides tiny Duquesne and Wilkinsburg, both of which send their older students out of district, there’s also Cornell (Neville Township and Coraopolis) with only about 500 students, and Brentwood and Northgate (Bellevue and Avalon) with about 1,000 students.

Besides the educational and administrative limitations that come with small sizes, it also costs more per resident to provide all the services a school district is responsible for. These small districts have some of the highest tax rates in the region: Brentwood residents pay over 37 mills, for instance, while Bellevue and Avalon residents pay nearly 29 mills. Compare that to under 20 mills in North Allegheny and Pine-Richland.

Mergers may not be politically palatable or prudent in every case, but the legacy fragmentation of the region’s public education systems is a major impediment to excellence and efficiency at the local level, and to reforms and new initiatives at the regional level. It is all but impossible, for instance, the implement a regional career and technical education strategy — something the region badly needs — because it would involve herding 43 school districts in Allegheny County alone. And that doesn’t even get to the surrounding counties.

The Rochester-New Brighton shared superintendent proposal is a creative move, showing that it’s possible, and likely fruitful, to explore consolidated leadership and perhaps services. It’s a way of seeing what works — perhaps leading to a full merger, or perhaps just learning about how small districts can work better together. We’d like to see more districts, big and small, experiment with these kinds of collaborations.

Advertise with us

Taking this a step further, County Executive Sara Innamorato should form a countywide public education council, consisting of representatives from each school district, to share ideas about collaboration, and possibly pursue countywide initiatives.

Across southwestern Pennsylvania, the organization of public education is a legacy from a very different moment in history. It’s going to require bold leadership and creative experimentation to optimize those systems for this moment, and the future.