A pair of measles cases in Erie County highlight the importance of vigilance against the disease, which is reliably prevented by a vaccine that has been administered safely for six decades. Progress against infectious disease is almost never permanent — smallpox is the only human disease to have been permanently eradicated — and requires effective prevention measures to be used across the generations. There’s no reason for measles to return.
Until the wide availability of the measles vaccine, now administered as part of the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) shot, the disease was a common childhood illness. Because it’s so infectious, getting measles for most people was a matter of when, not if.
Now, decades after vaccination has decreased measles cases in America from hundreds of thousands to just hundreds, it can be easy to imagine that the disease was a childhood annoyance. But that’s not the case. While deaths from measles are uncommon, they’re hardly negligible — about one in 500 cases. Because the disease spreads so rapidly, that means several hundred Americans, especially children, were dying from measles every year before mass vaccination. Still today, measles kills over 100,000 people around the world every year.
Luckily, the Erie County cases are reported to be from international travel, and health authorities say that community spread is all but impossible. That’s because most communities still have “herd immunity,” which occurs when a high-enough proportion of the population is immune to the disease, depriving it of hosts.
The problem with measles is that, because it’s one of the most infectious known human viruses, the herd immunity threshold is quite high: around 95%. Further, the MMR vaccine isn’t 100% effective — no vaccine is — with full protection at 97% after two doses. That means that it doesn’t take many people declining the vaccine for herd immunity to be lost, putting people who can’t take the vaccine — those with compromised immune systems, for example — at particular risk.
Vaccine hesitancy has been around as long as vaccines have, but the modern movement of skepticism or rejection can be traced to a 1998 paper by now-former physician Andrew Wakefield, which found a loose connection between the MMR shot and autism in 12 children. That study hasn’t just been disproven by much more extensive research: It was discovered to have been entirely fraudulent, including manipulation of data and undeclared financial conflicts of interest.
Still, the MMR-autism connection has endured in the public imagination, especially as trust in established institutions has declined. It is absolutely essential to understand that, no matter one’s views of established institutions, there is no evidence whatsoever that the typical risks associated with the MMR vaccine — soreness, a touch of fever, very rare allergic reactions — are worse than the diseases they prevent.
This year has provided tragic proof of that fact with the suspected measles deaths of two Americans, one in Texas and the other in New Mexico. Already 2025 is on track to have the most U.S. measles cases since an unusual spike in 2019, which dissipated when COVID emerged.
Meanwhile, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s recent advice to use vitamin A to ward off measles is radically incomplete. Vitamin A enhances immune function, but it provides no particular protection against measles. Further, overdosing on vitamin A — as the New York Times has reported is occurring in the areas of Texas affected by the measles outbreak — carries its own risks, including liver damage.
The only reliable way to protect oneself — and one’s family and community — from measles is to get vaccinated.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.