Affordable housing remains one of the most potent political issues, and social problems, in Pittsburgh today. The city lacks housing stock available to lower-income residents, and even the median priced housing isn’t affordable to people at the median income.
This has resulted in an exodus of thousands of low-income households, and especially Black households, over the past several years. Affordable housing was a key issue in the 2021 Democratic primary for mayor, in which now-Mayor Ed Gainey defeated then-Mayor Bill Peduto, in part due to his promise to make low-income housing affordability a priority.
Now, as Mr. Gainey faces a stiff primary challenge of his own from Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, the mayor has announced his Keep Pittsburgh Home initiative to elevate his administration’s housing successes, and to launch new proposals. This initiative, however, is too little, too late for an administration that has always been right to emphasize the importance of affordable housing, but that has struggled to generate a coherent strategy to create it.
The problems Mr. Gainey identifies in his Keep Pittsburgh Home pitch — especially out-of-town corporate meddling in Pittsburgh’s housing market — are real, and he’s right to lament them. But his solutions continue to be vague or even contradictory, and have often been undermined by the actions of his own administration.
Pittsburgh doesn’t need affordable housing posturing; it needs real affordable housing solutions.
A vague initiative
While the precise contours of the Keep Pittsburgh Home initiative are difficult to pin down — the administration has described it in different ways as different times — it seems to have four pillars, or puzzle pieces, as discussed in a press event on Friday: protect renters; support homeowners; regulate short-term rentals; invest in and improve public housing. Each of these is sensible, if vague. But the Gainey administration has made marginal progress, at best, in all of them.
Protecting renters and regulating short-term rentals can be rolled into a single piece of legislation approved by City Council in 2023, which created a rental registry encompassing all rental units in the city, from month-to-month lofts to Airbnb-style homes. The Editorial Board supported this effort, but the legislation remains mired in litigation, and will soon receive a final verdict from the state Supreme Court.
The rental registry does exist, in a probationary way, but is optional for landlords to participate in. Unsurprisingly, very few have. We hope the court will find in the city’s favor, but it’s odd to consider it part of a new or innovative housing initiative.
Supporting homeowners refers to a variety of Urban Redevelopment Authority-managed programs, such as OwnPGH down-payment assistance grants, that were created and funded during the Peduto administration. In fact, the Gainey administration reduced the amount of American Rescue Plan Act funding set aside for OwnPGH and other homeowner assistance programs. While Mr. Gainey is touting them now as part of his own housing strategy, it is unclear how or if he aims to make them more robust.
Investing in and improving public housing refers, at least in part, to the administration’s most notable affordable housing accomplishment: applying for and receiving a record number of Low Income Housing Tax Credits, a federal program to fund public affordable housing projects. However, as the Editorial Board has chronicled, the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh is a basket case, and no progress will be made on public housing until leaders face that reality.
Mr. Gainey promises more Keep Pittsburgh Home policies in the coming weeks, but after three years in office, it all looks more like last-minute electioneering rather than serious policymaking.
Bad corporate citizens
The most compelling part of Keep Pittsburgh Home is combatting the out-of-town corporate ownership of housing, which pulls homes off the market for uses like short-term rentals, increases prices and lowers safety and quality of housing. In identifying this, Mr. Gainey is absolutely correct — but beyond the rental registry he hasn’t proposed any specific policies that would address it.
In fact, the administration’s “Fair Housing Amendments,” which are currently on hold, would have made the problem far worse. By expanding the definition of a “family” for zoning purposes, while making unregulated and dangerous (for the residents themselves) “transitional” and “recovery” homes by-right uses across the city, the ordinance would have turned Pittsburgh housing into a Wild West for corporate exploitation.
Pittsburgh needs an anti-corporate-housing-takeover strategy, but Mr. Gainey has never had one.
Coherent strategy
Here’s two ideas: Remove barriers to building new housing so the city produces more units than corporations can scoop up, and emphasize affordable home-ownership, not just affordable renting.
Nowhere in Mr. Gainey’s Keep Pittsburgh Home strategy is simply increasing the housing stock, so more people can call Pittsburgh home. Further, as the Editorial Board has argued time and again, the mayor’s “inclusionary zoning” push would throw a wet blanket on housing construction. His other proposal to deregulate zoning would be just the ticket, but Mr. Gainey has insisted on lashing it to citywide IZ.
The Land Bank is moving some homes back onto the market and the tax rolls, for which Mr. Gainey deserves some credit. But he also removed useful ARPA funding from the bank, and his administration has yet to negotiate a key agreement that would make its work more efficient. It’s a success, but not as successful as it could be.
And then there’s affordable home-ownership, where the city gives prospective buyers a leg up over corporate vultures. The Peduto-era OwnPGH is a step in the right direction, but it’s not enough. Pittsburgh was poised to become a test case for affordable home-ownership with the community-based plan to build 100 for-sale homes in Larimer, in conjunction with the expansion of Bakery Square. But Mr. Gainey has placed that plan on ice, in favor of forcing more rental affordability within Bakery Square itself.
Ultimately, Mr. Gainey has struggled to make headway against unaffordable housing because he has lacked a coherent strategy to achieve his goals. Keep Pittsburgh Home looks to be just more of the same.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.