Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. has struck a blow for fairness and human decency by bringing charges against the owners of ailing affordable housing complexes around Pittsburgh. The decisive approach is demonstrating just how rotten much of the affordable housing industry is: It would be a good use of state resources for new Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday to make holding reckless, profiteering landlords accountable a staple of his term in office.
The charges specifically refer to the MonView Heights complex in West Mifflin, whose owners also control the decrepit Palisades Plaza in Rankin, along with several other properties around the region. But these are hardly the only examples of allegedly fraudulent practices and inhumane conditions in the affordable housing industry. Rent subsidies paid directly to property owners are meant to ensure high-quality housing is available to people struggling to make ends meet, and many landlords use those funds for the proper purposes: maintaining and improving their properties.
But the subsidies also serve as a beacon that attracts unscrupulous operators, who see in affordable housing an opportunity to provide cheap housing while pocketing the federal subsidies. That’s what Mr. Zappala has charged Jonathan Liani, Moshe Silber and Frederick Schulman with. The New Yorkers will face trial on charges of theft, receiving stolen property, and conspiracy, among others.
Further, at least one LLC in which Silber and Schulman are principals, NB Affordable, has purchased 11 other neglected properties in Western Pennsylvania, including roughly 1,000 units in Pittsburgh.
The three owners are accused of pocketing reimbursements from federal Housing and Urban Development (HUD) subsidies that were supposed to make the apartments livable, clean and up-to-date. Hundreds of thousands of public dollars allegedly ended up in accounts associated with the owners and their various LLCs, instead of invested in decent housing.
The apartment complexes they neglected made the news several times. The Palisades, for instance, received an inspection score of 0/100 in December, according to Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV, with officials citing leaking sewage, collapsing ceilings and broken hot water systems. Two months earlier, MonView Heights was flagged for multiple pest infestations and black mold. A 3-year-old fell through the kitchen floor of one of the units.
Remarkably, NB Affordable senior vice president of property operations Paula Kane actually published an op-ed in another Pittsburgh outlet when the company first acquired local properties in 2023. In the article, she promised to “invest” in the community, “upgrade units” and “create local jobs.” “There is no point to housing if you’re just going to let it fall into disrepair,” the NB executive wrote.
Two years later, hundreds of families are stranded in the roughly 1,300 subsidized housing units NB Affordable abandoned. Last month, Pittsburgh City Council discussed the issue in a post agenda meeting. Officials including U.S. Rep. Summer Lee and City Controller Rachael Heisler listened to contractors who were left unpaid by NB Affordable and tenants who experienced inhumane conditions.
It is an unfortunate fact that systems that are designed to help vulnerable people are often exploitable by those who see their vulnerability an opportunity for profit. These crimes often go undetected because the people who are hurt are among society’s least visible.
But there are state and federal laws that can be used to protect them, and to punish those who would exploit them. Mr. Zappala has done well in addressing these outrageous crimes, though there’s more work to be done here and across Pennsylvania. At the state level, Mr. Sunday should consider creating a task force specifically on the issue of affordable housing to show unscrupulous property owners that they’re being watched.
Clarification, posted Feb. 19, 2025: This editorial has been edited to more clearly express that Mr. Zappala’s charges regard the MonView Heights facility alone.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.