As money from opioid settlements funds addiction-fighting efforts nationwide, Pennsylvania’s own opaque disbursement oversight methods are posing a new question: Does helping children in the welfare system count as an accepted use of this money?
As SpotlightPA has reported in their extensive coverage of opioid settlement fund disbursements, tiny Cameron County, population 4,300, received mixed signals from state agencies about how the county can allocate its money. Nearly three years after the first opioid payments have been used, this type of ambiguity should be long gone.
All county spending decisions are overseen by the Pennsylvania Opioid Misuse and Addiction Abatement Trust, and funding parameters are defined by one document: Exhibit E. The scope of allowable spending in Exhibit E is intentionally sweeping to give counties latitude in how to approach the distinctive issues in their communities: support people with opioid addiction; fund prevention programs; and gather research on how to best meet these end goals.
These categories allow for funding for projects like school anti-drug campaigns, subsidized childcare for parents in opioid addiction treatment, or research into finding alternative treatments for chronic pain. Other uses, like upgrading police cruisers in Lawrence County, have rightly been deemed unacceptable by the oversight board.
Other programs, like a Butler County ‘Dope for Hope’ program, whose coordinator specializes in occult texts, have been approved. It’s clear that successful programs within communities aren’t held to evidence-based perfection: They simply have to work within the parameters of Exhibit E.
Still, Exhibit E can’t provide all the answers, especially without guidance from a transparent oversight board. This led to the mess in Cameron County.
From records requests, SpotlightPA reporters found county officials asked a member of the state Attorney General’s Office (the same office that negotiated the opioid settlement) for specific permission to use settlement funds to boost employee wages for the Office of Children and Youth Services, to allow the office to better serve young people in the county whose parents or guardians struggle with opioid use disorder.
There’s plenty of evidence that child welfare is inextricably linked to the opioid epidemic. Across Pennsylvania, the leading cause of all foster care placements involved a parent with addiction — roughly 35%, according to a 2023 state snapshot. In 2022 in Cameron County, it was 72%. Drug poisonings have surpassed physical violence as the most common serious injuries or causes of death in child abuse cases in Allegheny County.
A senior advisor from the AG’s office told Cameron County officials their proposed use was “clearly approved according to Exhibit E,” so county officials moved forward in spending $23,000 on pay increases. Then, in August 2024, two years after the initial guidance, the Opioid Trust declared the allocation invalid, forcing the tiny community to pay back the $23,000 it has already spent. Six months later, the entire mess is still in dispute between the county and the trust.
Frustratingly, the Opioid Trust is not required to disclose the reasons for its decisions, leaving everyone involved to guess at them. If the board believes that funding services for the children of people with opioid use disorder isn’t a direct enough response to the crisis, however, just consider this: Providing stability to children whose families have broken apart due to opioids can help prevent the crisis from being passed down to the next generation.
Opioid payments will continue for another 18 years. Cameron County should provide a lesson to the Opioid Trust on what murky guidance inevitably produces: confusion and waste. The board must become more consistent and more transparent.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.