Pittsburgh saw a significant drop in shootings and homicides between 2023 and 2024, signaling a return to levels that were normal before the numbers spiked during the pandemic. The city suffered 41 homicides in and 81 nonfatal shootings, down from 52 and 118, drops of roughly 21% and 31%, respectively, from 2023.
Preliminary data suggests this reduction mirrors similar declines seen at the county and national levels, and thus might be a welcome trend and not a statistical accident. Much more work will be needed to know what this decline means.
Analyzing crime statistics at scale is fraught with challenges. The sheer volume of data, combined with regional differences in tracking and categorization, makes comprehensive analysis difficult. Only some crime is tracked, and some localities don’t collect data at all.
Still, while the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s comprehensive analysis won’t be available until next year, the current numbers show progress. Even better: this positive development extends to youth and children, fewer of whom have been killed or harmed by these crimes than in previous years.
These statistics are cause for optimism, but they only tell part of the story about community safety and well-being.
Statistics, and their limits
Another part, a very important part, is told by what are called “quality-of-life crimes,” such as public camping, drug use and harassment of pedestrians. These can reduce public safety and just as importantly for the life of a city, significantly affect citizens’ perceptions of safety. These offenses may not carry the same weight as statistics as do shootings or homicides, but they deeply affect community well-being.
These low-level offenses can disproportionately shape how safe people feel, even as violent crime trends downward. Just like talk of a strong economy and low unemployment felt hollow in the face of inflating grocery bills and rent prices during this year’s presidential campaign, public officials touting low violent crime rates can feel irrelevant or disingenuous in the face of homeless encampments and public drug use.
Statistics showing that some crimes didn’t occur somewhere else can’t overcome peoples’ worries about what they see in front of them — worries that are often compounded by rumors and the perception that the problems are worse than they are.
The city and county must address quality of life crimes if the people of the city and the county are going to feel safe Downtown and in many other places.
As this Editorial Board has argued, this requires more effective policing (and more police officers). Crime statistics are not the best way to track the larger, complex issues affecting our public spaces, and relying on these statistics to enforce the law will not result in the best outcomes.
Many of these individuals would be better served by housing and treatment, not incarceration, job loss and forced withdrawal. As the Board has argued many times, addressing Pittsburgh’s quality of life crimes requires greater and more effective investments in social services and infrastructure to meet these underlying needs. Making vulnerable peoples’ lives better will do much to change peoples’ negative perceptions.
Without such efforts, the disconnect between statistical progress and public sentiment will persist.
Other metrics
To truly understand and address community safety, and public perceptions of community safety, it is essential to look beyond crime statistics, and towards the larger issues that feed into quality-of-life crimes. Some of the most important include housing and drug use.
This month, the federal “Point in Time” report from the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) showed an 18% increase in homelessness nationwide between January 2023 and January 2024. HUD cited factors such as rising immigration, a severe shortage of affordable housing and escalating rental costs.
Locally, Pittsburgh’s housing crisis mirrors these national challenges. Affordable housing stock remains critically low, with many families and individuals unable to find stable shelter. Temporary solutions like increased shelter beds or transitional housing are just that: temporary.
Similarly, Pennsylvania’s opioid crisis continues to shape community health. Overdose deaths peaked in 2017 and have since decreased due to interventions like the increased availability of Narcan, but the drug supply remains in flux. Contaminants like fentanyl and xylazine continuously introduce new challenges.
And, the overall decrease in overdoses has not been felt equally; in 2018, as fentanyl was introduced, the rate of overdose deaths among Black men in Allegheny County began to sharply diverge from the rest. Even when the larger trends are good, marginalized people suffer more.
Intertwined issues
These statistics can only reveal facets of the larger problems and solutions. These intertwined issues — homelessness, addiction, and violent crime — illustrate the complexity of creating safe and thriving communities. They also underscore the limitations of relying solely on statistics.
The rate of violent crime is still an important metric for measuring the well-being of communities. In this category, Pittsburgh and the nation are moving in the right direction. However, it’s important to acknowledge that a low level of murder and shootings is only one part of community safety and overall community health.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.