In 1907, with the pugnacious and progressive Theodore Roosevelt as president, America celebrated Thanksgiving weeks after the country had suffered a major financial crisis. Wall Street shenanigans had led to a major bank failure in New York City, and the contagion threatened to spread across the American financial system. The Pittsburgh Stock Exchange, located on what is now an empty lot on Fourth Avenue, closed for three months.
Roosevelt, meanwhile, had been attempting to use both law and moral suasion to rein in the incredible power of American business interests. Leading up to the Panic of 1907, he had even accused these interests of conspiring to tank the U.S. economy — hurting millions of everyday people — in order to discredit his administration’s attempts at reform.
National greatness
It was in this context that Roosevelt dedicated his Thanksgiving proclamation to the theme of national greatness — but not greatness simply seen as wealth and power. He argued that while prosperity is essential to greatness it is not sufficient.
Americans needed to be committed to justice, righteousness and good character to ensure the blessings of prosperity are shared by all, and don’t lead to inequality and decadence. The goods for which Americans should be thankful brought with them responsibility.
Americans had many reasons to be thankful. “During the past year we have been free from famine, from pestilence, from war. We are at peace with all the rest of mankind,” Roosevelt began. “Our natural resources are at least as great as those of any other nation. ... Nowhere else in the world is there such an opportunity for a free people to develop to the fullest extent all its powers of body, of mind, and of that which stands above both body and mind — character.”
He then evoked the Biblical parable of the talents, in which Jesus contrasts two servants, each of whom is entrusted with a fantastic amount of money by his master. One servant, timid and lazy, returns to his master the same amount he was given. The other servant, clever and industrious, has increased his master’s wealth, and returns more than he was given.
We must be the second, Roosevelt declared. “Much has been given us from on high, and much will rightly be expected of us in return. Into our care the 10 talents have been entrusted; and we are to be pardoned neither if we squander and waste them, nor yet if we hide them in a napkin; for they must be fruitful in our hands.”
National duty
Always, and for everyone throughout human history, “prosperity has been fraught with danger, and it behooves us to beseech the Giver of all things that we may not fall into love of ease and luxury; that we may not lose our sense of moral responsibility; that we may not forget our duty to God, and to our neighbor.”
For Christians through the centuries, and for Roosevelt, this meant that the person — or the society — to whom much has been given, even more is to be expected. Our thankfulness for what we have, as individuals and as a nation, does not mean much if we don’t use what we have to make everyone better off.
It’s hard not to see this proclamation as a shot at the industrialists he blamed for the crisis, who did not see the world and our human duties that way. Our fellow Americans are not just workers or customers, but neighbors.
The president insisted that we must be more than simply grateful. “A great democracy like ours, a democracy based upon the principles of orderly liberty, can be perpetuated only if in the heart of ordinary citizens there dwells a keen sense of righteousness, and justice.”
Whatever we have, we and the nation can be better. “We should earnestly pray that this spirit of righteousness and justice may grow in the hearts of all of us, and that our souls may be inclined ever more both toward the virtues that tell for gentleness and tenderness, for loving kindness and forbearance, one toward another, and toward those no less necessary virtues that make for manliness and rugged hardihood; for without these qualities neither nation nor individual can rise to the level of greatness.”
National hope
Roosevelt ended his proclamation with the traditional declaration of a late Thursday of the month as a day of national thanksgiving. He asked Americans “to thank the Almighty for the many and great blessings they have received in the past” and — this is important — “to pray that they may be given the strength so to order their lives as to deserve a continuation of these blessings in the future.”
In the end, the Panic of 1907 looked like a victory for Wall Street: J.P. Morgan bailed out the banking system, and Roosevelt was forced to approve U.S. Steel’s takeover of a Tennessee steel company, whose failure threatened to deepen the crisis. But out of this moment came one of the most important financial reforms in American history, and a remarkable increase in government power: the Federal Reserve System.
As we gather to give thanks this year, let us remember that America’s greatest reserves aren’t in oil or money, but in the democratic virtues we have inherited and are tasked with developing and deploying for the betterment of all, and that we can exercise in gathering with friends and family on this day.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.