The unqualified security company to which the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh (HACP) illicitly awarded a contract earlier this year, as revealed by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, has notified its employees and the authority that it will abandon the contract on Dec. 11. This represents another embarrassment for the embattled agency, and lends credence to suspicions that the contract award to 3G Security Solutions was politically motivated.
Above all, it represents HACP’s failure to take seriously its own responsibility to preserve security and peace of mind for Pittsburgh’s most vulnerable residents.
3G’s owner, Jennifer Dintini, a Republican candidate for state Senate this year, gave her 30-day notice only days after she lost her bid to state Rep. Nick Pisciottano. At least one law enforcement agency is probing the authority’s procurement practices, but abandoning the contract during the campaign would have been politically embarrassing and attracted further attention to the scandal.
Further, most 3G security guards are represented by the influential union SEIU 32BJ, whose local president, Sam Williamson, sits on the board of the Urban Redevelopment Authority, which works closely with HACP.
In July, the Editorial Board reported that HACP had taken the unusual step of awarding part of a security contract to Ms. Dintini’s company despite the fact it ranked — as reported in the very resolution approved by the HACP board — as the “second most responsive, responsible and qualified firm” to place a bid. Specifically, the authority split a proposed contract for armed and unarmed security services, and gave the more lucrative armed-guard contract to the less-qualified firm, up to nearly $5 million over three years.
This excluded long-time HACP security contractor OSA Global, on whose contract the armed-guard responsibilities were crudely scratched out by hand. OSA has now been tapped to take over the entire contract after 3G’s resignation.
After receiving the armed-guard contract in May, 3G was supposed to begin work at the end of July. A source with direct knowledge of HACP security informed the Post-Gazette Editorial Board that 3G was not prepared to begin work at that time, and sought extensions beyond the 30- and 60-day delays allowed for in the contract. Ms. Dintini’s firm finally took over the duties in its contract on Sep. 29, a full nine weeks late. Yet the company was still unprepared, and had to use guards employed by its predecessor, OSA Global, to fulfill its responsibilities.
Only six weeks later, after the Nov. 5 election, Ms. Dintini finally ended the charade by giving her 30-day notice.
The series of events confirms that 3G was never qualified or prepared to take on the responsibilities of protecting residents at HACP properties, and strongly suggests that the authority was willing to put its residents at risk as part of a contracting scheme benefitting a politically connected company. Since midsummer, security at several of the authority’s facilities has been inconsistent while 3G struggled to cobble together enough workers to fill shifts, and was unable to provide qualified supervisors.
The episode has all the hallmarks of a clumsy and dangerous attempt at bid-rigging, and we renew our call for an investigation that connects all the dots.
The Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh, meanwhile, continues to operate as if nothing unusual is going on, even as the Editorial Board has identified several suspicious contracts awarded by the agency. There appears to be no pressure for, or even interest in, reform from the agency’s board — which is chaired by Jake Wheatley, chief of staff to Mayor Ed Gainey. Unless and until the board demonstrates that it can act responsibly, a wider investigation into HACP’s practices and leadership will be necessary.
Because right now, the agency is serving neither its residents nor the taxpayers that fund it. The question is: Whom is it really serving?
Editor’s note: On Dec. 8, the Post-Gazette published a letter to the editor from 3G Security owner Jennifer Dintini responding to this editorial. The letter can be found here.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.