Mayor Ed Gainey’s budget and state-of-the-city address to Pittsburgh City Council this Tuesday reflected a startling disconnect with the reality he has overseen during his nearly three years in office. Several of the claims Mr. Gainey made in the address were simply untrue, while others gave impressions that he must know — or at least should know — are false.

The address revealed, in the clearest form yet, the foundational myth of the Gainey administration: that the mayor inherited from Bill Peduto a city government in shambles. While no local government of this size is ever in perfect condition, and Mr. Peduto was far from a perfect mayor (as this Editorial Board noted), the truth is that Mr. Gainey inherited a government where professionalism and efficiency had been steadily improving. That is no longer the case.

And he inherited a city that, until the COVID pandemic, had been experiencing a renaissance of optimism. While peer cities like Cincinnati and Cleveland raced out of the gates as the pandemic abated, Mr. Gainey’s Pittsburgh has remained stagnant, and pessimism has settled back in.

But perhaps the most dangerous thing of all for the people of Pittsburgh is that — as our conversations with people knowledgeable about the administration have shown time and again — Mr. Gainey and many members of his inner circle genuinely believe much of their own bluster. They really believe they inherited a mess; they really believe they’re doing great; they really believe almost all criticism is unfair or prejudicial.

Advertise with us

Improvement requires realistic assessments of one’s own circumstances, and of one’s own shortcomings. But Mr. Gainey is no longer connected to reality, and so improvement is impossible.

Fact-checking the mayor

“I don't know if I ever thought a budget address would need to be fact checked but here we are...” wrote City Councilman Bob Charland of the South Side on X, linking to a story from WPXI’s Rick Earle outlining the fabrications and exaggerations in Mr. Gainey’s remarks.

It’s a somewhat naive statement: Shading the truth comes with the territory as a politician, especially when touting one’s own accomplishments. But Mr. Charland is right to say that it’s particularly troubling, and indeed galling, that the mayor would mislead so brazenly in an address, directed at his own City Council, that is meant to be a relatively dry explanation of his proposed budget.

The most remarkable of Mr. Gainey’s claims reflects a deeply troubling politicization of the health and safety of the people of Pittsburgh. The mayor bragged that “the Bureau [of Emergency Medical Services] has been able to deploy a greater number of basic life support units at one time than at any time in its history.” These “basic life support units” are emergency medical technicians, or EMTs, who have been trained by his administration’s new Freedom House EMT Training Academy, which appears to have been genuinely successful.

But, as the Editorial Board has previously reported, the EMS Bureau as a whole is in a deep crisis. The bureau may have more EMTs, who primarily provide support, but it is understaffed by dozens of paramedics — who require much more training and can do much more for ill or injured people than EMTs can. This has led to rolling closures of EMS stations and record payments to suburban agencies to help cover special events.

Advertise with us

Touting a few new EMTs while ignoring the missing paramedics is like announcing that a victim of a car accident is doing great when you’ve bandaged his bruised knee — while he bleeds out from a severed artery.

Taking responsibility

But it wasn’t just EMS where Mr. Gainey attempted to pull the wool over Council’s — and all Pittsburghers’ — eyes about a matter of public safety. He also did it about the police, who are experiencing the worst staffing crisis in their history.

The mayor said, “In 2022 I reopened the police academy, after several years without recruits which was rapidly dwindling our number of officers.” This is, simply put, shameless. Those “several years” go back to 2020, when Bill Peduto paused police academy training not due to negligence, but due to COVID.

Then, when Mr. Gainey took office in 2022 he inherited, as the Editorial Board revealed last spring, plans and funding for two classes of police recruits — but he never called them. Only in mid-2023 did he finally bring recruits to the academy, but by then the staffing crisis was already beyond fixing. While it’s certainly arguable that Mr. Peduto should have reopened the academy sooner, Mr. Gainey owns the lion’s share of responsibility for the city’s ongoing public safety crisis.

Back to reality

There’s not enough space here to discuss every instance of deception in what’s supposed to be a simple explanation of next year’s budget. We could, for instance, discuss how Mr. Gainey has completely failed to deliver on his main campaign promise of expanding affordable housing — while squandering tens of millions of dollars in free federal pandemic aid that could have helped him reach his goals.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, his attempts to force affordability by fiat will only result in less housing being built for Pittsburghers of all income levels.

But what makes all this all the more disturbing is the sense — confirmed to members of the Post-Gazette Editorial Board — that Mr. Gainey and many of his clique of lieutenants have become so ensconced in their little world on the fifth floor of the City-County Building that they don’t recognize many of the city’s problems as their responsibility. It’s either, nearly three years later, Mr. Peduto’s fault or the (largely compliant) media’s fault.

This insulation from the real life of the city all but forecloses the possibility of making improvements, because to do that you have to recognize the problems. That is, you have to be in touch with reality. And, in his own budget address, Mr. Gainey made it clear that he isn’t.