“Narcan vending machines are a commonsense way to save lives” read the headline of a Post-Gazette editorial early last month, praising Allegheny County’s installation of free overdose-reversal medication dispensers at several locations around the county. Unfortunately, the county purchased generic vending machines that were not suited to the Narcan distribution program.

As a result, only one of the seven machines promised by the county is functioning; four have yet to be even installed; and two of three that had been placed have had to be replaced — only to malfunction again. It’s a clear case of bureaucratic dysfunction, and a consequential mistake that leaves vulnerable people without one way of saving their or other people’s lives.

This failure is a particular problem for County Executive Sara Innamorato, whose progressive vision of government entails robust interventions to solve, or at least to mitigate, social problems. Her success depends on demonstrating the kind of competence that builds public confidence in the public sector.

Botching the rollout of a relatively simple and genuinely life-saving program undermines that confidence in a serious way — but also provides an opportunity to enhance trust by admitting failure and doing right by the county’s partners.

Advertise with us

A worthy program

Enhancing Allegheny County’s harm reduction efforts has been a focus for Allegheny County Health Department, and there’s no question it’s been successful. The county’s Department of Health has distributed about 35,000 doses of Narcan this year alone, at two doses per kit, and enhanced accessibility to the drug through pop-up events and by making it available by request through the county’s website.

Narcan is the brand name of a nasal spray form of naloxone, which blocks and reverses the effects opioids like fentanyl in the human body. In so doing, it can bring overdosing drug users back from the brink of death. The medicine is safe to distribute in a relatively uncontrolled way because it does not produce any of the euphoric effects of opioids, and therefore cannot be abused.

Vending machines in outdoor public places allow drug users, or people who care for them, to access Narcan in a simple, immediate and barrier-free way, either as a preventative measure or during an acute overdose episode. The availability of Narcan does not encourage drug use, and during the first several weeks of the abortive program, there was no immediate evidence of the machines serving as hubs of other illegal activity.

For the program to work, the vending machines have to work. With just one exception, they don’t.

A botched rollout

Here are three basic considerations that should have gone into selecting vending machines for the Narcan project: ensuring the machines are rated for outdoor use; ensuring they can keep the medicine within its indicated safe range of temperatures; and ensuring that the machines’ distribution slots were big enough for the Narcan boxes to pass through. Unfortunately, none of these considerations were heeded.

Advertise with us

The main reason only one of seven machines remains functional is that the machines the county bought — for a program that only makes sense if the medicine is available in a public outdoor space at all hours — were designed for indoor use. That means they aren’t watertight, nor are they climate-controlled.

So when it rains, the machines take on water and eventually stop working. And when it gets cold, the medicine will freeze.

While there is good evidence that Narcan remains safe and effective after freezing — a person administering the medicine should hold it closely in their hands for several minutes to accelerate its thawing — Pittsburgh’s winter temperatures are below those indicated on the box for safe storage. That could trigger the fear of liability issues for the county, even if it is nearly impossible that anything would go wrong.

But perhaps the most ridiculous aspect of this mess is that the Narcan boxes don’t even fit in the machines’ corkscrews, which are clearly designed for bags of snacks. The Brookline vending machine, at the Tree of Life Open Bible Church, has the unboxed kits in the corkscrews, so they’re small enough to get out of the machine.

This requires additional volunteer work and almost certainly violates one or several arcane regulations — but it’s the only way to make the medicine available to those who need it. That the church saw the problem and has the volunteers to do this is the one reason the county’s one machine is working.

Advertise with us

Competence and humility

Despite these entirely preventable setbacks, the county reports that several hundred Narcan kits were obtained from the few functional machines in just their first few weeks of operation. The program saved lives. That’s the reason it must be done right.

National and local evidence demonstrates that increasing the availability of Narcan correlates with a decline in fatal overdoses. For instance, in the year since the Biden administration made Narcan available over-the-counter there has been a 10% decrease in overdoses — the largest decline ever recorded.

In other words, policy matters, and government policies based on solid evidence can and will make a difference for everyday people, including saving lives. Those policies have to be executed in a competent way, or else they will fail — and people’s confidence in government will falter as well. Failure affects more than just the one botched program.

This isn’t just true among the general public, but also among the government’s partners. Organizations that participate in harm reduction programs regularly face community opposition, and it’s disrespectful to those partners to botch the government’s end of the deal.

Restoring confidence will mean Ms. Innamorato admitting candidly that the county blew it, and promising to procure appropriate machines as soon as proper procedures will allow. The apparent early success of the 500-in-500 housing affordability drive shows that it’s possible for the young administration to marry high-minded principles with competent nitty-gritty execution. This is an opportunity to show that it also has the competence — and the humility — to fix its mistakes.

And more importantly, to save lives.