A timely and professional performance audit by Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor has provided a rare glimpse inside the county’s Department of Human Services (DHS), and particularly its struggling Homeless Assistance Program. The results demonstrate that the agency simply does not have the capacity to respond to the rise in homelessness in Pittsburgh in recent years, in large part because it does not receive enough funding from the state of Pennsylvania.

But the audit also revealed shortcomings that are within the control of DHS — most importantly, that the so-called “bridge housing” centers it contracts with are regularly not filled to capacity, even as the waitlist for them has ballooned to nearly 450 people. That means that while the county’s shelter emergency system is overtaxed, leading to hundreds of people living in tents, the agency has struggled to free up shelter beds by moving clients to transitional housing options.

This finding points toward a longer term problem for DHS: It is habitually reactive to social services crises and rarely proactive about arranging systems in a strategic way to move people, slowly but surely, from homelessness to renewed independence. County Executive Sara Innamorato’s 500 in 500 plan to bring online several hundred units of deeply affordable housing is an encouraging step in the right direction, but it also highlights the missing link between shelters and permanent housing — that is, transitional or bridge housing — identified in Mr. O’Connor’s audit.

So while DHS’s homeless services absolutely need an influx of funds from Harrisburg, they also need a more comprehensive approach — one that sees emergency shelters as truly emergency, and that builds the capacity to move clients progressively, step by step, from living on the streets to living independently.

Advertise with us

Shelters overtaxed

Mr. O’Connor’s performance audit was an excellent use of the authority of the controller’s office. It fairly identified areas for improvement without exaggeration or grandstanding, and made intelligent recommendations for reform. In particular, in identifying state funding as an underlying issue, the audit should kickstart conversations in Harrisburg about funding county social service agencies more fairly.

In the past three years, Allegheny County has seen an unprecedented increase in the unhoused population. After a spike during the first year of the COVID pandemic, the annual point-in-time count actually dropped in January 2021, to a total of 689 homeless individuals, including 118 in “supportive housing.” But it has risen substantially every year since, to a high of 1,164 this January, a nearly 70% increase.

During the same period, however, the number of people in supportive housing, which largely refers to transitional units where social and health services are regularly available, remained nearly constant. It was 118 in 2021, and 138 in 2024, an increase of only 17%.

In other words, while DHS scrambled to catch up with the wave of homelessness that swept the nation by ramping up shelter space, it struggled to effectively move people out of shelter and into bridge housing when they were ready. As a result, the average stay in emergency shelters, as revealed by the audit, remained well above the agency’s 30-day target. During the audit’s scope of July 2022 to June 2023, nearly half of all people who used the county’s emergency shelter system stayed longer than a month.

Reactive, not proactive

This is particularly frustrating when, as Mr. O’Connor’s audit reveals, the available bridge housing options have consistent vacancy rates of 30% to 40%. DHS director Erin Dalton, in her office’s response to the audit, frankly admitted that efficiently moving people from emergency shelters to transitional housing has been a struggle for the agency.

Advertise with us

That’s in part because of unavoidable downtime, while bridge housing units are cleaned and renovated between tenants. But it’s also because DHS contracts with several small facilities, resulting in a fractured system dependent on the competency of each individual provider. And DHS can’t keep up consistently with all of them.

This points to a broader problem: DHS has focused nearly exclusively on responding to homelessness by increasing emergency shelter capacity, but has not built out a consistent system for moving clients forward in their journey to renewed independence. The result has been a revolving-door shelter system — combined with a revolving-door criminal justice system, as demonstrated by the growing encampment near the county jail — where the same people are served on an “emergency” basis time and again.

Therefore, as much as the agency’s inability to keep existing bridge housing full is a problem, the bigger issue is that bridge housing capacity hasn’t increased in recent years. This is symptomatic of a lack of foresight and of a comprehensive strategy: The agency is reactive rather than proactive.

State funding

In fairness to DHS — and this is another strength of the O’Connor audit, which showed him to be more interested in finding solutions than assigning blame — its capacity to strategize and to execute has been clearly hampered by insufficient funding from the state.

For the audited fiscal year, from mid-2022 to mid-2023, the DHS Homeless Assistance Program received $2.6 million, while its expenses totaled $12.6 million. The extra $10 million is made up by moving county funds that are meant to be used for other purposes, such as mental health services. That appropriation remained constant the next year, and for 2024-2025 state leaders passed a $5 million increase statewide, which amounted to only about $500,000 for Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

While there is immense competition for state dollars, there’s hardly a more important investment in the well-being of Pennsylvanians and the livability of the state’s communities than homeless services. Mr. O’Connor’s audit should initiate a movement to increase that funding substantially for next year.

Even so, however, additional funds will only be useful if the agency has the foresight to be able to use them wisely — including, especially, developing a plan for moving people progressively from homelessness to independence. By pinpointing this issues and offering real solutions, Corey O’Connor’s audit may prove to be a turning point for the agency.