A year and a half after the Post-Gazette Editorial Board first reported on a missing $10 million in federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) money that had been set aside for the Office of Community Health and Safety (OCHS), there’s still no clear answer to where the money has gone.

At the same time, despite plans to boost the office with money from the city’s Stop the Violence Fund, the Gainey administration has struggled (once again) to fulfill its promises. Plans to spend an additional $1.5 million in the first quarter of this year never materialized, according to the city’s quarterly financial report. It is unlikely that the $4 million set aside for the rest of the year will be spent, either.

This is particularly disappointing as the city faces a historic homelessness crisis. Going into the Gainey years, OCHS was poised to be a progressive and effective service-provider. Instead, it has been mired in confusion and controversy.

Former Mayor Bill Peduto founded OCHS in 2021, and the office quickly established a presence in Pittsburgh’s streets. It was making progress toward “co-response” operations with City of Pittsburgh firefighters and police officers when it came under media scrutiny, including in these pages, in early 2023. That’s because city documents showed $5 million appropriations for 2022 and 2023, but there was no record of the funds being spent, nor of enhanced operations to match such a windfall.

Advertise with us

It turned out that the $10 million in ARPA pandemic relief funds were meant to support a burgeoning collaboration between OCHS and AHN called ROOTS, or Reaching Out On The Streets. This program was developing street medicine sites around the city and offering alternative response (as opposed to co-response) services, where health and social-work personnel, rather than police officers, would respond to people in crisis.

But the contract between the city and AHN was never signed. Instead the Gainey administration has funneled more Stop the Violence Fund dollars into OCHS in order to support ROOTS as an entirely city-run program. The office’s budgeted staffing has surged to 52, but only 34 of those positions were filled as of the end of June.

There isn’t necessarily anything wrong with this approach to funding OCHS, except that the administration has never explained why the AHN relationship was scuttled, nor what became of the $10 million in ARPA funds.

On the bright side, the Department of Public Safety announced last week that OCHS is about to launch a Post Overdose Support Team with a million-dollar federal grant. This is the kind of program OCHS was made for, and its creation now only further highlights what could have been in the previous three years.

OCHS should have been a key player in tackling Pittsburgh’s homelessness crisis, and its current growth shows that it still can be. Unfortunately, however, it has been consistently hampered by financial shenanigans and bureaucratic incompetence. And Pittsburghers (not to mention the feds) still deserve to know what happened to that $10 million.