A mid-year report of the City of Pittsburgh’s current and projected revenues presents a dire portrait of the city’s finances while completely vindicating the watchdog efforts of City Controller Rachael Heisler. Meanwhile, after previously casting doubt on Ms. Heisler’s work, Mayor Ed Gainey and Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Director Jake Pawlak had the gall to host a “fireside chat” where they presented the disastrous revenue findings as evidence of the city’s financial health.

This is nothing less than a fraud being perpetrated on Pittsburgh taxpayers. Mr. Gainey and Mr. Pawlak are either knowingly lying about the city’s financial health, or they have deluded themselves into believing a brazen falsehood. The only reason the city is not projected to blow through its entire, and until recently quite healthy reserves by 2027 is that expenditures, too, have come in lower than expected.

The reason? Among other things, the administration has struggled to hire for all the positions it has created. In other words, the only thing slowing the city’s descent into financial oblivion is the Gainey administration’s incompetence at fulfilling the tasks it has set out for itself.

The report, and the happy-talk about it from Mr. Gainey and Mr. Pawlak, show the administration to be far more invested in its own reputation than in financial future of the city. Its promises have been proven to be false time and again, and there’s no good reason to trust new claims that all is well. Without mature leadership, the damage to the city’s fiscal health could linger for decades.

Advertise with us

Controller is correct

This spring, Ms. Heisler’s office prepared a report on city revenues that challenged the assumptions on which Mr. Gainey’s 2024 budget, and subsequent five-year projection, were based. The report pointed to predictable revenue shortfalls the budget had ignored, such as cratering commercial real estate values and the likely demise of the “jock tax,” and derived a worst-case scenario: a $14 million revenue shortfall this year, followed by shortfalls of $20 million to more than $30 million every year through 2028.

At currently-budgeted expenditure levels, this would deplete the city’s reserves by the end of 2026, triggering state oversight — and possibly desperate measures like a commuter tax — shortly thereafter.

The Gainey administration responded dismissively to the Controller’s warnings, appointing a “city finances task force” that consisted entirely of the people whose day job it is to manage the city’s finances: no fresh eyes, no outside perspectives, no independent experts. Unsurprisingly, the message that emerged from the task force’s work last week was that Pittsburgh’s finances are just fine.

But that’s not at all what the numbers indicated. In fact, the new official OMB projections for 2024 through 2028 are as bad or worse than Ms. Heisler’s worst-case scenarios. And they’re still being artificially propped up.

False projections

Mr. Gainey and Mr. Pawlak have long argued that 2025 and 2026 were going to be lean years for Pittsburgh. That’s because federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds, which had been used to supplement the city’s budget to the tune of nearly $50 million a year, run out at the end of this year. Further, payments on the city’s debt will increase from about $70 million this year to nearly $80 million in 2026, before dropping down to $50 million in 2027.

Advertise with us

But this would have been manageable with a proper plan. Instead, the administration has significantly increased budgeted spending figures while inflating projected revenues to cover for it.

This includes failing to account for predictable declines in property tax receipts and the deed transfer tax, which dropped a staggering $12 million due to a slowed pace of property sales. Further, the administration has continued to collect, and to budget based on, the so-called “jock tax,” which has been struck down as unconstitutional by multiple state courts. It is imprudent — to say the least — to continue to rely on the tax based on nothing more than the hope that the state Supreme Court will dash precedents and rule in the city’s favor.

This habitual inflation of revenues makes it all the more frustrating to hear Mr. Pawlak describe the administration’s projections as “conservative.” They have never erred on the side of caution, and there’s no reason to trust they’re starting now, especially with the primary election in the offing.

Incompetence squared

The only reason for hope is that expenditures have also come in below budget — but not because of efficiencies. It’s because the Gainey administration has been unable to accomplish the tasks it budgets for, including hiring for positions it creates.

Despite a shrinking population and an unsteady tax base, budgeted staffing for city government is at highest level in at least a decade at over 3,600 positions, when jobs paid for by trust funds like the parks tax are factored in. But fewer than 3,300 of those positions are filled. While it’s typical for there to be openings, a nearly 10% shortfall is unusual, and indicates that the administration simply doesn’t have the capacity to spend the money it budgets.

Advertise with us

Further, this year’s expenditures are coming in under budget only because the administration left so much of last year’s budget for line items such as “professional services” unspent. This is not money the city saved; it’s money the city set aside, but failed to use for its intended purpose within the fiscal year. Typically, about $10-15 million gets rolled over. This year, $35 million got rolled over, juicing the budget and giving the impression the administration is saving money when it isn’t. Rather, it’s deferring spending into the future.

The bottom line is this: Controller Rachael Heisler’s warnings about Pittsburgh’s financial future are accurate, and the Gainey administration’s own figures prove it. The reckoning is coming, either on the balance sheet or at the ballot box.