A local journalist’s lawsuit settlement, which affirmed that Allegheny County Bureau of Corrections employees may talk to the media as private citizens, has spurred a nationwide call to action from the Society of Professional Journalists.
Brittany Hailer’s settlement is the first awarded to a journalist, as opposed to an affected public employee, setting the stage for other members of the media to push back against unfair and unconstitutional gag rules imposed by government agencies.
These employee policies, which often prevent workers from speaking to the press without the approval of a media liaison or other higher-up officials, clearly infringe on First Amendment rights. Public employees have a protected right to talk about work-related topics as private citizens.
These policies are continually struck down as unconstitutional, yet government agencies across the nation persist in enforcing them. Now, the push to dismantle them isn’t restricted to these employees — and the SPJ is celebrating, asking journalists across the nation to join in on the effort.
The damage these restrictions cause goes beyond infringing on the personal freedoms of employees. They prevent journalists from doing their jobs, keeping the public from accessing important information about the internal workings of institutions like the Bureau of Corrections that only on-the-record sources can provide.
Ms. Hailer’s case against Allegheny County Jail is a perfect example. Then the director of the Pittsburgh Institute for Nonprofit Journalism, she brought the case in 2023 after finding that multiple employees and contractors at Allegheny County Jail were afraid to share information with her on the record.
The policy required employees to obtain express permission before granting interviews, and employees who made statements without permission were regularly disciplined. The intended effect was to keep embarrassing information from getting to the public.
This was during a time when the jail’s inmate death rate was twice the national average, and a shortage of medical personnel was putting inmates in danger. It was of inherent public interest that the 1,500 incarcerated people in ACJ, their families, friends and the larger community understand what was happening.
Allegheny County eventually settled the case this April, agreeing to new policies removing restrictions on whether and how Allegheny County Bureau of Corrections employees can speak about their jobs, post on social media, and talk to the press.
This should be only the beginning. Gag rules have become more popular in recent years, shutting down the ability of public employees in all sectors from sharing important knowledge and expertise — and dispelling misinformation. Journalists across the nation should push back against policies that shut the public out of the public sector.
They are a First Amendment violation that has been allowed to continue for too long. And now, journalists are able to fight back — and the Post-Gazette looks forward to joining the fight.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.