From South Side encampments overflowing with furniture to tents taking over the Three Rivers Heritage Trail behind the Allegheny County Jail, increasingly visible clusters of tents are once again becoming the most salient reminder of the ongoing homelessness crisis in Pittsburgh.

A recent police raid at an encampment along Grant Street near First Avenue showcased how dangerous encampments are — for homeless people. Two criminals, both with valid home addresses, systematically targeted encampment residents, using their tents to stash drugs and coercing homeless people to serve as low-level dealers, according to police reports.

It’s a disturbing reminder of how easily criminals can take advantage of the vulnerable. Drug dealers are not known for their care for other human beings. Police noted that officers struggle to investigate tents where people live, for good reason — and the criminals respond accordingly, moving drugs between different shelters. The Grant Street encampment’s established nature allowed criminal activity to run rampant for weeks leading up to the raid.

Earlier this year, homelessness and its comorbidities had been limited to one small fraction of Downtown: the triangle of buildings, including a courthouse, a rehabilitation center, and an encampment surrounding Allegheny County Jail. Most people didn’t see it.

Advertise with us

This hodgepodge system of shelters was destroyed when a fire at Second Avenue Commons in early June shut down the facility. Its 188 residents were immediately displaced, moving first from the convention center and then to a temporary shelter at a Pittsburgh Mercy facility on Reedsdale Street. Roughly 100 people entered unsheltered homelessness in a matter of weeks.

Second Avenue Commons is slated to reopen in a limited capacity later this year, including its medical clinic, overflow shelter, and nearly 100 beds. But, like every city and county plan regarding homelessness, the relief is still months away.

Feeling the strain

Now, Three Rivers Heritage Trail users are feeling the strain, as one of Pittsburgh’s most scenic and popular amenities has increasingly become home for those with no other recourse. Even compassionate nonprofits like Friends of the Riverfront, which helps maintain Pittsburgh’s 33 miles of river trails, recently urged visitors to report encampment issues like overflowing garbage or unleashed dogs to local elected officials. An updated page on their website is dedicated to discussing encampment issues.

Their statements, which respectfully acknowledge homeless people as fellow trail users, underscore the strain the influx of tents has put on even the most compassionate community organizations.

The city is offering garbage cleanup and regularly removes unused tents. But, lacking any shelter capacity, encampment sweeps would only shuffle the problem around, and maintenance, not abatement, is the only option.

Advertise with us

The county, meanwhile, is planning, but not for the short-term. A request for proposals in July for a winter shelter offering beds for up to 75 clients hinted at a coordinated, long-term response being launched. But its supporting documents paint a more alarming picture: The county is requesting a private-sector miracle.

It requires a private party to put in a herculean amount of work just to get the plan started and then to sustain it. They must first locate, pitch, lease, and possibly rehabilitate new shelter locations — with the approval of nearby stakeholders. Once the new shelters are functioning, they must employ and supervise a full staff — not an inexpensive part of the effort — and provide transportation for all clients from downtown to the shelters.

RFP documents also acknowledge that this shelter will likely still be necessary even after SAC reopens. None of it will be enough.

One proposal left

With encampments only growing citywide, and shelter space stagnant until winter, the city has only one proposal left to help corral and contain tent cities: temporary managed communities.

These tiny homes or tent communities offering services, security and stability are an imperfect but proactive solution first proposed by Councilmembers Deb Gross and Anthony Coghill last year. It remains the only viable way to boost shelter options fast. But it’s been caught in bureaucratic limbo.

Advertise with us

Temporary managed communities require an update to the city’s zoning code to allow “interim housing” models. The zoning would allow these structures in all areas approved for hotel/​motel zoning. The Planning Commission, which first received the proposal last December, is currently collecting public comment on its draft proposal.

But the zoning changes won’t be considered for final Planning Commission approval until September, and if approved won’t reach city council until weeks after. The city has no chance of implementing the measure to address current summertime homelessness.

An innovative, proactive plan is withering on the vine as encampments return to public spaces all over the city. No city or county leaders have moved fast enough, or with a coordinated enough plan, to bring a viable solution to fruition.

In the meantime, maintaining encampments is the worst, and only, option.