Repeated closures of Mount Washington’s Monongahela Incline in recent years have devastated businesses on the top of the hill that depend on the funicular to deliver customers, putting unfair pressure on Shiloh Street small businesses with thin margins. But a simple shuttle from the Duquesne Incline, one mile away, could be an economic lifeline that ensures the benefits of the inclines are spread more evenly.

When the Mon Incline goes down — which has happened several times, for weeks or months at a time, over the last two years — Pittsburgh Regional Transit offers a replacement shuttle service from Station Square to bring visitors up the hillside. While this is a good solution for commuters, it’s not helpful for tourists and other visitors who are looking for the unique incline experience.

Those people don’t want a bus: Many of them go down West Carson Street to the Duquesne Incline.

While the walk between the two upper stations along Grandview Avenue is only a mile, it’s a hilly stretch that’s difficult for people with disabilities or young children, especially in the summertime heat. And regardless, what keeps the ice cream parlors and bakeries and bars and restaurants of Shiloh Street and its surroundings going is the fact it’s convenient, not that it’s part of an exercise tour.

Advertise with us

Connecting the two inclines, and the unique amenities offered on each end of Grandview, would boost tourism for both funiculars and the businesses surrounding them.

The Duquesne Incline and its original, preserved cabins draw those with an eye for history, or those with a preference for the iconic view of the Point. High-end restaurants like Monterey Bay Fish Grotto and Altius are a short walk away.

A mile south and east, the Mon Incline serves commuters looking to connect to other transit modes at Station Square, and more casual tourists who don’t want to drive down Carson (and pay to park). This is where Mount Washington’s Shiloh Street thrives, less than a block away, where visitors grab a soft serve and stroll to the nearby observation decks.

But, without any shuttle service between them, these two ecosystems remain separate. When the Mon Incline goes down, visitors who opt for the Duquesne have no easy way to get to the incline-optimized businesses of Shiloh Street. While business owners estimate their losses differently, overall the cost is 20% to 40% — much worse during high-tourism seasons.

PRT has declined to provide a shuttle that does anything more than replace existing service. That leaves the City of Pittsburgh and Mount Washington Community Development Corporation. It shouldn’t be hard for the two to work together on a free connection between the inclines, for when the Mon is malfunctioning. The cost would be more than covered by increased business.

Pittsburgh has two inclines, but they seem to exist in separate worlds. Connecting them will help the funiculars serve their purposes better, and help Mount Washington’s unique businesses survive.