The Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board, recently bolstered by a new slate of members — including the regular attendance of County Executive Sara Innamorato — is nonetheless falling into old habits of acrimony. This time, the dispute is over “unannounced inspections” performed by board members at-large County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam and Muhammad Ali Nassir, who uses the name MAN-E.
There was a time when Ms. Hallam’s antics and intransigence served a purpose: bringing public attention to the desperate conditions at the county jail. But the time for a disruptive presence is past. Council President Pat Catena should remind Ms. Hallam that she serves on the board entirely at his discretion. And if she continues to disrupt more business than she conducts, he should exercise that discretion.
“Unannounced inspections” are both an obligation and a privilege of membership on the JOB. State law indicates that the board as a whole “shall, at least twice each year, conduct an unannounced inspection of the prison's physical plant.” This is not happening, but it should begin — led by Ms. Innamorato.
Allegheny County’s JOB bylaws extend the state rule to a privilege held by individual board members to conduct such “inspections” at their discretion. But the bylaws also require that each inspection be accompanied by “a written report to the Secretary within 10 days of their visit setting forth the date, time, nature/purpose of their visit, findings and determinations.” According to President Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente, Ms. Hallam and MAN-E have failed to file these reports in a timely manner.
More than that, documents reviewed by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board allege that the couple regularly visit incarcerated friends and family members during their “inspections,” an abuse of the privilege.
The ensuing argument at last Thursday’s JOB meeting turned the new board into a version of the old. Members argued fruitlessly about the board’s bylaws, discussed whether Ms. Hallam’s spandex shorts violated the jail’s guidelines, and scolded one another for looking at their phones. It was, once again, a juvenile embarrassment.
These arguments crackled during a meeting where much more important business was under consideration: Members were briefed on the hiring of a new warden, and an internal survey revealed grueling working conditions for correctional officers. The infighting has also obscured a bright spot in ACJ’s record: No incarcerated person has died in the jail thus far this year.
Last fall, when a crowd of public commenters berated retiring warden Orlando Harper, we said that the JOB had become “performance art” rather than an effective public body. For Ms. Innamorato’s first six months, that wasn’t the case. But here we are again.
The board seat Ms. Hallam occupies belongs to “the President of County Council or their designee.” That designation lasts “until written notice of their revocation is received by the Board Secretary.” That means Mr. Catena can un-designate Ms. Hallam with the stroke of a pen. He should indicate to Ms. Hallam that he is willing to use that pen.
The time for purposeful grandstanding to bring attention to a neglected institution is past. Now is time for solutions.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.