To advocate for statewide real estate assessment reform has been, for decades, rather like advocating that the flow of the Ohio River be reversed or that state liquor stores be privatized or that Pirates owner Bob Nutting spend generously on the franchise: that is, something beyond the scope of human possibility.

But suddenly, a sign of progress: State Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, has announced a policy hearing that will explore the shortcomings of Pennsylvania’s absurd system of ad hoc county-by-county assessments on Monday at 1 p.m. in the Gold Room at the Allegheny County Courthouse. He will be joined by Sen. Katie Muth, D-Montgomery, who serves as the Chair of the Senate Democratic Policy Committee — a sign of seriousness on this issue from legislative leadership on the other side of the state.

The task ahead is challenging: convincing a majority of members of both houses of the General Assembly — most of which represent counties that rarely reassesses properties — that regular reassessments aren’t just for the good of the commonwealth, but also won’t get them destroyed at the polls. The former argument is easier to make, but the latter isn’t impossible. Because at the end of the day, consistent reassessment of properties will bring Pennsylvania in line with every other property tax state, and will be best, on the balance, for everyone.

Arcane assessments

Pennsylvania is the only state that allows counties to decide when to perform a full reassessment of property values, unless a court intervenes. This means that every county calculates its assessed values — that is, the value to which the tax rate is applied — based on widely varying “base years.” For instance, Allegheny County last reassessed in 2012. Washington’s base year is 2015, but before that it was 1981. Beaver reassessed just last year. Butler, on the other hand, is operating in 1969.

Advertise with us

This means that tax rates across counties can’t be compared, because they’re based on radically different property valuations. For instance, the millage rate in the Seneca Valley School District in southern Butler County is 138.32, or 13.832% of property value every year. Compare that to North Allegheny School District, right across the border in Allegheny County: 19.73 mills, or 1.973%. But, because Butler County property values are pegged to 1969 and Allegheny County’s to 2012, in practice Butler residents pay less in taxes.

This system is made possible by the notorious common level ratio. The CLR takes account of the difference in market property values between the present moment and the base year. Then, when either a property owner or a taxing body challenges the property’s assessed value, the CLR is used to calculate the new assessed value from the market value.

This is arcane, but remarkably important. Over time, as market conditions change, property values diverge — this is measured by another figure called the coefficient of dispersion — and the one-size-fits-all CLR works less and less well. Generally speaking, homeowners in areas with rising property values do better, because their assessed values don’t keep up with the market, while people in stagnant or declining areas do worse, because their assessed values match or outstrip the market.

Scheduling earthquakes

Altogether, this means that inequality of taxation both within and among counties tends to increase the farther removed they are from the base year. This also means that reassessments become more economically and politically destabilizing the farther removed they are from the base year.

The result is a system that pits counties against one another and appears to punish those that reassess while others stand pat. It’s also a very difficult system to reform, because the overwhelming incentives not to reassess lead especially smaller counties to dig in. This makes the prospect of a new round of reassessments — and especially state-mandated reassessments — very unpopular.

Advertise with us

Think of it like a fault line between tectonic plates. The longer between earthquakes — when the fault slips — the more pressure is built up, and the more violent the next quake will be. Pennsylvania essentially allows counties to decide when to schedule their earthquakes, but no one wants to be responsible for the consequences of ordering one. So the pressure builds, and builds, and builds.

The only fair and safe solution is to do what other states do: Require counties to reassess on a regular basis. That stops the pressure from ever building up too much in any one place while relieving local officials from the responsibility of ordering up a tremor.

Stability, even when it hurts

And that’s what Mr. Fontana and Ms. Muth want to do. The Montgomery County senator posted on X that 50 of Pennsylvania’s 67 counties haven’t performed a full reassessment in the past 15 years. That’s a lot of pressure building up. That’s a sign of a broken system.

How often should the state mandate reassessments? In Ohio, it’s every six years, while in Maryland it’s three. We’d propose every three years here, with a third of counties on the hook each year.

While it will be a bigger initial adjustment in those 50 counties, in the long run both property owners and taxing bodies will have more stable and predictable taxation systems. No more wrangling over the CLR for years or decades. No more “newcomers tax,” when taxing bodies appeal assessed values after real estate transactions. No more worries among taxpayers about big reassessment tax bumps. No more incentives to game the system, or to perpetuate an unfair and unsustainable system.

For Mr. Fontana — himself a real estate agent — it would be a tremendous capstone to a distinguished career. For Gov. Josh Shapiro, it would be a legacy reform that makes Pennsylvania better. For members of the General Assembly, it would be the right thing to do — and, in the long run, their constituents will thank them.