New revelations about the Gainey administration’s purchase card (“p-card”) scandal, uncovered through Right To Know Law requests, raise further troubling questions about payments made by the Pittsburgh Department of Parks and Recreation to Mario Ashkar. Most prominent among them: Did city officials direct Ashkar to submit a fraudulent invoice to retroactively bring paperwork into line with a less embarrassing timeline of events, after Ashkar was identified as a suspect in antisemitic vandalism?

This is one of over 20 questions posed in a statement last Saturday by City Controller Rachael Heisler, who continues to perform her watchdog role with commendable vigor. Every one of those questions deserves a public answer. The Gainey administration’s stonewalling of the independent office’s inquiry, and ignoring of its legitimate public questions, is itself scandalous.

Ms. Heisler’s aggressive pursuit of the truth makes it clear why the Mayor’s Office declined to cooperate with her inquiry into the matter, opting instead to open an in-house investigation through the Office of Municipal Investigations (OMI).

Like most political scandals, the p-card episode is complicated. Here’s the gist: After Ashkar’s arrest for antisemitic vandalism of a private home, it came to light through Ms. Heisler’s office that they (Ashkar uses they/them pronouns) had been paid for services on a regular basis by the Department of Parks and Recreation. After an initial payment via invoice, which is typical for this kind of arrangement, the payments shifted to p-card transactions, which are subject to less scrutiny than invoice payments. This violates the city’s regulations for paying for professional services.

Advertise with us

Further, Ashkar was rehired for contracting work less than a year after being fired for poor performance. The state ethics code requires at least a year before public employees are paid in other roles.

The new revelations deepen the scandal by showing that Ashkar submitted two invoices for their final days working for the city. The first included hours worked from April 24 to 28. The second removed those hours, but added hours for the prior week.

April 24 is the day police identified Ashkar as a suspect in the vandalism. The communications suggest a) that city officials communicated with Ashkar after they were identified as a suspect but before they were arrested on May 9; b) that Ashkar continued to work for the city after being identified; and c) that officials helped Ashkar cure their final invoice so it would appear they did not work after April 24. That would be fraud.

Curiously, the emails released by the city focus almost entirely on one official, Parks and Recreation Director Kathryn Vargas. In one message, written just after the issue came to light, she wrote with unusual directness: “I am the only person to blame if there is a problem with our having worked with [Ashkar].”

Meanwhile, emails that fulfilled the Right-to-Know request from Office of Management and Budget Director Jake Pawlak are redacted in their entirety. No reason was given for this remarkable redaction.

Advertise with us

We continue to be suspicious, as we wrote immediately after the scandal broke, that Ms. Vargas is being set up in order to isolate the scandal within Parks and Recreation. And we are concerned that an in-house OMI investigation will lack the curiosity Ms. Heisler has shown, and return a report that narrowly focuses on Ms. Vargas and her department.

The public deserves better. Pittsburgh deserves answers to Ms. Heisler’s questions.