Juneteenth is meant to be a celebration of life and liberty for Black Americans, as it commemorates the final promulgation of emancipation in Texas on June 19, 1865. And that’s what it will be this year, its fourth as a federal holiday, here and around the country.
Unfortunately, in Pittsburgh this year “Juneteenth” has also become a byword for acrimony and fecklessness in City Hall. Fights over funds for multiple Juneteenth festivals have divided the community and added an unnecessary layer of intrigue to the festivities.
The decision to fund two separate Juneteenth festivals with $125,000 each was probably the best solution to a problem that shouldn’t have festered as long as it did. But it’s also an unsustainable solution: In a city staring down fiscal collapse, where a service as basic as street paving is on the chopping block, shelling out a quarter of a million dollars to keep dueling festival promoters happy is hardly a long-term plan.
A different direction
Most of Pittsburgh’s great parties, such as Labor Day and St. Patrick’s Day, are put on by private groups on their own dime, with the support of city services such as public safety. Independence Day, however, is a production of the city’s Special Events office. In addition, more or less since the demise of the Three Rivers Regatta, the city also ponies up over $100,000 in cash, largely for fireworks.
Faced with this situation, Mayor Ed Gainey argued — not wrongly — that it would only be fair for the city to put matching funds into a Juneteenth festival. While Independence Day is for all Americans, Juneteenth recognizes Black history and struggle in a particular way that deserves to be honored, especially in a city that has made it unusually difficult for Black people to thrive.
This is where things got complicated.
Dueling festivals
Pittsburgh already had one of the nation’s most well-established Juneteenth festivals, organized by event producer William “B” Marshall. So last year, City Council approved spending $250,000 over two years to support Mr. Marshall’s party. Controversially, this included federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds that had been set aside to fund local artists — just as the Gainey administration also used “arts” funds for the Independence Day fireworks.
Details are sketchy, but it’s clear last year’s arrangement ended acrimoniously, with allegations of unpaid bills and poor management traded among Mr. Marshall, the city and the state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources (DCNR), which manages Point State Park. At some point, the Gainey administration decided to go in a different direction, despite last year’s two-year commitment.
Their solution was to put together an official, city-sponsored Juneteenth festival, which would focus on local arts, thus more clearly fulfilling the objectives of the ARPA funds. But this plan also required putting the party’s management out for bids. Mr. Marshall saw this as reneging on his deal with the city, and the bust-up only deepened when, in early May, the administration announced Bounce Marketing as the city’s official Juneteenth promoter.
Bounce is owned and run by Fantasy Zellars, who managed Mr. Gainey’s inaugural celebration. She is also a friend and business partner of Michelle Gainey, the Mayor’s wife: In March, they co-curated a Downtown art exhibition called “Resilience and revolution: Honoring Black History and Women’s History through art.”
The connections among all these individuals and organizations raise a variety of questions of propriety, to which there are no easy answers. It is clear, however, that the supply of Black-owned major event planners and promoters is not huge in Pittsburgh, a city that has lost over 20,000 Black residents since 2000. It is terrible that this drama has cast a pall on festivities meant to uplift the Black experience in Pittsburgh.
Juneteenth without drama
In the end, Pittsburgh will fund and get two Juneteenth festivals this year. City Council felt, rightly, that it couldn’t renege on last year’s two-year commitment to Mr. Marshall, nor could it fail to fund Mr. Gainey’s “official” Juneteenth. Despite the acrimony, the everyday people of Pittsburgh should see this as a happy outcome: two opportunities to celebrate a holiday too-long set aside, and now brought into the mainstream where it belongs.
Today is the last day of Mr. Marshall’s bash at Point State Park and Market Square, which carried the theme “We are Family.” As we write on Friday, the weather looks good (if hot), and so we hope and expect the event will have been a success.
The city’s “official” Juneteenth will be a smaller affair, hosted in and around the Greenwood Plan Building at Smithfield and the Boulevard of the Allies on June 29. Its title is “Fusion Fest” and will particularly emphasize local Black arts and culture. We hope and expect this, too, will be a success.
But this political and personal rancor can’t reoccur next year. The Gainey administration must decide now how it will handle Juneteenth 2025, and that can’t involve distributing taxpayer dollars (and especially federal ARPA funds) to satisfy promises made to multiple event promoters.
One possibility: ditch private promoters entirely, and run Juneteenth out of the city’s Special Events office, just like the Fourth. Another: let Mr. Marshall’s Juneteenth rise or fall on its own, without city funding, just like Labor Day and St. Patrick’s Day rise or fall based on their private organizers’ work.
In fairness and in fiscal prudence, the city should also seek private sponsorship for the Independence Day fireworks, as well.
It will fall to Mr. Gainey to ensure that, next year, Pittsburgh can celebrate a Juneteenth where the only drama is on the stage.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.