It’s no surprise that the final integration of Negro Leagues statistics into Major League Baseball statistics has provoked a firestorm of discourse. And in all the headlines has been one of Pittsburgh’s greatest athletes, the incandescent Josh Gibson — who should be immortalized by a statue at PNC Park.
Gibson, who played 13 seasons for the Pittsburgh Crawfords and the Homestead Grays, has shot to the top of several MLB categories, including career (.372) and single-season (.466) batting averages. Does this mean he is now, officially, the greatest batter in baseball history?
The very question misunderstands the nature and importance of bringing Negro Leagues data out of the appendices of baseball history and into the main text: It’s not about crowning a new lifetime batting champion, but about ensuring that the greats of segregated Black baseball are included in the conversation alongside their peers — where they belong.
Baseball has always been the most quantifiable great American sport. For this reason, its statistics are considered sacred by fans in a way football, basketball and hockey statistics are not.
But this elides the fact that even in baseball, statistics are at least as much art as science. For instance, what is a “hit”? That depends on what a fielding “error” is. And the definition of an “error” is subjective, based on expectations of what plays an average player should make, and those expectations have changed over the generations — along with pitch speed, equipment quality and, well, pharmaceuticals.
It’s all a matter of perspective. The important thing is that Josh Gibson now appears in the same book as the other legends, and will be included in conversations about the all-time greats in the mainstream, rather than only among aficionados.
Even in Pittsburgh, where he moved at the age of 12 and died in 1947 from complications of brain cancer at the appalling age of 35, Josh Gibson has largely been relegated to the footnotes. He was buried in an Allegheny Cemetery plot that only received a marker in 1975. There’s a baseball field in the Hill District named in his honor, and North Charles Street in the North Side carries his name on an honorary basis.
But does he come up in conversation alongside Bradshaw and Clemente and Lemieux? No, and that is wrong. And the reason is because the Negro Leagues have been unjustly relegated to the class of historical curiosity, rather than an essential antecedent of the modern Major Leagues.
By integrating the record books, MLB has taken a big step in the right direction. Josh Gibson’s great-grandson, Sean Gibson, also wants the league to sponsor an annual Negro League Day, where all the players would be honored by teams’ wearing Negro League uniforms. We agree.
As for Pittsburgh, four legends are already immortalized with statues around PNC Park: Roberto Clemente, Honus Wager, Bill Mazeroski and Willie Stargell. Nothing would be more fitting than adding Josh Gibson to the roster.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.