The Allegheny Lawyers Initiative for Justice this month published a wide-ranging report outlining exactly how the county can address its lackluster indigent defense system. Based on hundreds of interviews with attorneys, decades of media coverage and dozens of nationwide studies, the ALIJ has put in immense legwork to support their findings: The county just needs to listen.
Americans’ right to an effective attorney regardless of ability to pay was enshrined in the Constitution’s Sixth Amendment in 1791, but only finally confirmed by the Supreme Court in 1963. But in states like Pennsylvania, where it’s almost entirely up to individual counties to fund and manage indigent defense, poor defendants are often left at the mercy of a system that could assign them overworked and underpaid representation.
Roughly 80% of people charged with a crime don’t have the means to hire a lawyer. In a country where incarceration and recidivism are sky-high, that means poor defendants suffer the most.
In Allegheny County, indigent defense is provided by the county Public Defender’s office and by court-appointed private attorneys. The ALIJ report has recommendations for both systems.
These reforms include altering the reimbursement rates for private attorneys who take on poor clients, especially regarding the reimbursement “caps” that limit total compensation. While hourly compensation rates were thankfully increased in 2023, as called for by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, the county caps still in place don’t account for the reality of modern criminal cases. This can include reviewing hours of body camera footage or scouring thousands of pages cell phone data.
Reimbursement caps, which function as flat rates for cases, make it financially impossible for court-appointed attorneys to provide a proper defense with full compensation.
Further, while prosecutors can easily tap law enforcement, criminal investigators and medical examiners for their cases (all with the support of paralegals), defense attorneys are left alone to build a case. Only 4% of local indigent defense attorneys ever get the help of investigators or experts. The only proper solution is to create, as much as possible, resource parity between both sides.
The ALIJ report also calls for a larger shift in attitudes toward criminal defendants. The holistic model pioneered by a Bronx nonprofit offers lawyers the support of social workers to handle clients’ non-legal needs, like addiction and mental health treatment. Roughly 80% of state prisoners suffer from addiction, and half have a mental health disorder.
Integrating social workers into indigent defense represents the next step in reforming the criminal justice system — and it also happens to save money in the long run: In the Bronx, the model saved $165 million in incarceration costs, without any harm to public safety. Allegheny County should consider the same approach.
Now is the time to strike for reforms. County Executive Sara Innamorato has promised to make reform a priority, and County Controller Corey O’Connor is in the midst of an audit of the indigent defense system. For both officials, the ALIJ report should guide their work and inform their decision-making.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.